32
Motherboard sales are now collapsing amid unprecedented shortages fueled by AI
(www.tomshardware.com)
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
I'm not here to argue for or against LLMs in general, but self-hostable AI is a thing. Actually open AI is a thing.
A blanket statement saying about AI as a whole technology being good for fascism is about as useful as saying "roads are good for fascism" (they're great for troop movement after all).
You can't self host anything when the hardware is no longer affordable.
I recently saw a Hacker News article on people running some Deepseek V4 Flash variant on macOS, which is a surprisingly capable model for its size
Self hosting an llm ain't the same thing as self hosting nextcloud for your docs and calendar. Yes there are small models but their output is laughable
Small models are improving and becoming more capable. The quality of local LLMs is basically unbounded. The context size of local LLMs is bounded by hardware. So local LLMs can be very capable for small, self-contained tasks.
qwen 3.6 35b running locally:
Single shot. No tool/internet use, so it didn't pull this script from elsewhere.
Output:
I tried to keep the size and scope within something that would reasonably fit in a comment. Looks pretty decent to me, but I can't write Python myself. Never learned. I double-checked the LAT & LON of Miami, and it's spot on.
It did take 47 seconds, while a cloud LLM would probably take 5 or less.
All I'm saying is local LLM isn't garbage and it is getting better all the time.
That's interesting.
How much ram did it use while running?
If you used a GPU, how much does it cost in today's prices?
It's a MacBook Pro. 36GB of ram. I am sure Macs have some kind of gpu and I understand it somehow combines GPU ram with system ram, but I don't really know Mac hardware very well.
It's beefy for a laptop, but the desktop I built for myself several years ago had 32 GB of ram and a GTX 1660, so I'm guessing they are similar in capability. I gave that to my daughter, so I can't run a comparison right now.
EDIT: After doing just a bit of research, I've learned the unified memory architecture that Macs use, while not ideal for many purposes, is actually a big advantage for running larger inference models. So it's possible that this particular model wouldn't run at all on my Linux box or would run much slower because the full model wouldn't fit in the 6GB of VRAM and create a lot of memory thrashing.
Yup, you want memory accessible to the GPU for local AI. AMD Strix Point and Mac devices are popular options. CPU can run LLMs but very slowly. I've got 32 GB of RAM and 8 VRAM and it's borderline useless for models that don't fit in the VRAM.
You see hot that's tangential to what you're replying to?
Your point is completely valid, but in another discussion.
Sorry, but I think the point about local AI not necessarily being evil is the tangent here.
The OP is about motherboard shortages, which is being driven by the big AI companies and is making hardware unaffordable for normal users
The top level reply to that is about how that's bad because it removes the ability for people to be in control of their own computing
Then someone comes in, saying "yeah, but you can host your own AI so that it's not evil so not all AI is bad"
Then someone points out that you can only host your AI if you can afford the hardware to do so which, as the OP and the comment you replied to pointed out, is getting really hard to do.
if you did not understand the comment from above it's fine but splitting hairs like you are doing is silly (everybody knows it's not 100 % of AI is 100% evil)...
your comment is exactly the same as when people say "guns don't kill people, people kill people"... yes, we all know guns are not autonomously killing people, the point is that guns, as a tool, are remarkably good at doing something we do not want, which is to kill people
Not to go on a separate tangent, but that's the entire point of guns. They are supposed to kill. That's not meant to be some crazy conservative defense of them or opposition to regulating them. Just pointing out something that seems to get lost in conversations.
Corps want to privatize roads and make them all toll roads too