35
Pluribus S01E06 - "HDP" Discussion
(hexbear.net)
Rules for Movies & TV Discussion
Any discussion of Disney properties should contain a (cw: imperialism) tag. If your post isn't tagged appropriately it will be removed.
Anti-Bong Joon-ho trolling will result in an immediate ban from c/movies and submitted to the site administrators for review.
On Star Trek Sunday only posts discussing how we might achieve space communism are permitted. Non-Star Trek related content will be removed and you will be temporarily banned until the following Sunday.
Here's a list of tons of leftist movies.
spoiler
After watching the first two episodes I had hoped that this series wouldn't get bogged down in the sort of technical worldbuilding that is constantly picked apart and accused of having plot holes, but unfortunately that is the route it has decided on (and it took way to long to get there imo, episodes 3-5 were pretty uninteresting).I guess I wanted Gilligan to do something to subvert the Invasion of the Body Snatches trope he lifted, but making the collective conscious (communist stand-in) cartoonishly evil with their cannibalism means the premise is way less interesting than it could be. I thought maybe it would be a commentary about American chauvinism in an increasingly global and multipolar world, but it seems like Carol's boorish, plucky, American individualism will be validated after all. Really disappointing that yet another protagonist in American media unironically yearns for the status quo and is presented as a hero for it. I don't buy that Carol is meant to be unlikable. It seems clear to me that her fellow uninfected and we (the audience) are supposed to come around to her way of thinking.
I mean, it's so close to being interesting (Carol rolling her eyes at someone from the Global South owning seven cars; how does she think that someone like Koumba would have viewed her lifestyle prior to the infection?), but I doubt that there will be any self reflection on Carol's part in this series. Maybe it's a perfect show for an American audience after all
Lmao absolutely saw this coming. But honestly I didn't see them being anything other than a disaster considering countless died to get to this point
They're not cartoonishly evil, they're basically vegans.
Vegans but waiting for widespread prion infection
If I can continue to riff on my "this is mindless American chauvinism slop" bit, then the two are one and the same to USians
Spoiler
I don't think I agree with your take.. I don't think they made the hivemind cartoonishly evil at all. I get that cannibalism is inherently evil and one of the universal taboos, but it's not like they are eating people alive or farming them, and given that the hivemind isn't necessarily human it doesn't feel evil. I also don't think it's expected for you or anyone in the show to be siding with Carol, in fact to me it feels like quite the opposite. She's very unlikable, every action she takes is actively harming the lives of the people she says she cares about. I'd be floored if the end of this show ends with her being a hero, and it would completely ruin the show for me. However, given how this last episode went it doesn't feel like it's moving in that direction at all.I do agree that I don't see much room for Carol to have any semblance of self-reflection in the coming episodes though, I think she'll die in vain, kill herself, or give up and allow them to assimilate her.