706
I love it
(programming.dev)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 28 Jan 2026
706 points (95.1% liked)
Programmer Humor
29603 readers
1174 users here now
Welcome to Programmer Humor!
This is a place where you can post jokes, memes, humor, etc. related to programming!
For sharing awful code theres also Programming Horror.
Rules
- Keep content in english
- No advertisements
- Posts must be related to programming or programmer topics
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
xdotoolis not already installed, and also will not work 🙄It does work but if you’re using Wayland, it won’t. But one would be rather silly to expect an X11/Xlib tool to work without X11.
Yeah, I wouldn't expect it to work, so I wouldn't expect a meme to imply that Linux has great backwards compatibility, when things change somewhat rapidly in mainstream Linux, making it quite hard to maintain.
X11 isn’t Linux… Linux is excellent for backwards compatibility. Can’t say the same about userspace though.
You're right! And yet it doesn't really matter that much, does it?
Yes, it does. Not only for servers, but every single application that wasn't written for X11 specifically continues to just work. Which is the vast majority.
Would you enjoy trying to explain this to your grandma or other stereotypically tech-un-savvy relative after you got her to install Ubuntu and something she was able to do before stopped working after an update?
You're interested in backwards compatibility on servers, and in backwards compatibility for a subset of applications. Cool. Convenient for you! Recognise that there's more to it than that, that when people meme about how awesome Linux is compared to Windows, focusing on servers and non-graphical applications isn't good enough.
Not backwards compatibility. Straight up compatibility.
and yes, I wouldn't mind. I enjoy explaining things.
The meme isn't implying great backward compatibility. It's implying great tool maintenance and availability.
I'm going to miss
xdotool(andwmctrl) when my distro eventually ditches X11.I don't use them often, but I do use them, and their functionality is nice to have.
There are partial replacements out there, but last I checked, they were very weak approximations.
what do those do? I run x11 but never knowingly used them
They allow the user to script changes to, and pull information from, windows in the window manager. Like read, if not also set, a window's title, change a window's dimensions, move it around, send it to a different desktop, send keypresses, bring a window to the foreground, etc. etc.
Basically, anything the user can do with the mouse, keyboard or window manager via the GUI, and a little more besides, can be automated.
The two commands work slightly differently to each other and one can often do something the other can't.
As an example, I have a script that resizes the active window to a 4:3 ratio at full vertical height on my 16:9 monitor. I've then bound that script to a keypress in the window manager. It's a lot like having something halfway between window mode and maximised mode.
Couldn't I do that with the mouse? Sure. But with the script I don't have to gauge by eye and spend multiple mouse clicks and movements trying to get it just right.
That sounds absolutely amazing and something that I'm definitely going to be looking up when I go on my desktop later. Thank you for informing me
Be aware that a lot of distros will be switching from X11 to Wayland at some point in the not-too-distant future and these ancient tools will not work there.
People have tried to write equivalents (
ydotoolis one I'm aware of), but Wayland has intentionally been written to make doing such things difficult, for "security" reasons.I will be grumpy until I can make my scripts work again, but that's for future me to deal with.
Yeah, sadly, I'm aware. I know that Wayland is making its rounds. I'm not looking forward to it. I try it every once in a while to see if it's gotten better, but so far, every time I've tried, I have artifacting and tearing, which just doesn't happen on X11