226
the FDA is considering a ban on menthol cigarette sales
(www.verifythis.com)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 04 Oct 2023
226 points (95.9% liked)
Mildly Interesting
17347 readers
3 users here now
This is for strictly mildly interesting material. If it's too interesting, it doesn't belong. If it's not interesting, it doesn't belong.
This is obviously an objective criteria, so the mods are always right. Or maybe mildly right? Ahh.. what do we know?
Just post some stuff and don't spam.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Banning drugs or alcohol has never worked. The demand will still be there. People will turn to the black market instead if it gets banned.
There is a whole arc in the Battlestar Galactica reboot series that masterfully illustrates this topic.
Yeah, which is why illegal drugs have more users than legal drugs (alcohol and tobacco). Except they don't.
Their argument was that banning cigarettes wouldn't eliminate their use, only drive people to continue doing it through other methods.
What does your comment have to do with that..? Nobody said there would somehow be more users than before, just that people would continue doing it..
My argument is that since illegal drugs have significantly fewer users, prohibition does reduce usage.
That logic doesn't flow, though. You need to compare number of current illegal users vs number of users before it was illegal.
Have you heard of the US prohibition on alcohol? It's a pretty famous counterexample to your argument showing that it absolutely does not reduce usage.
The same number of people, as a percentage, smoke marijuana as smoke cigarettes. Marijuana use is federally illegal and illegal in most states.
So no, it really doesn't reduce usage. Price and perceived risk are the two factors that reduce usage the most.
I don't know about the USA, but I see tobacco smokers every day and very rarely see marijuana smokers.
Most people smoking weed aren't just doing it out in the open like tobacco users
Well, then the prohibition has pretty much fulfilled its purpose.
When the government makes something illegal, they don't do it in hopes of millions of people doing it anyways in private.
Maybe not for other laws, but it makes sense for drugs. The important thing is that people should have the right to breathe non-poisonous air, and forcing smokers to hide their smoking achieves that.
This ban is on the sale of menthol infused cigarettes. It wouldn't criminalize smoking menthols and there's plenty of other ways to infuse cigarettes with menthol or buy a synthetic alternative.
If your point is at all that this prohibition would in any way, shape, or form help fulfill that goal, that is incorrect.
If you read the comment chain, we've been talking about drug prohibition in general, not this specific ban.
I've read the comment chain, it just seemed like you were implying that this ban would achieve some kind of beneficial outcome.
It's fine if I'm wrong, that's okay. I'll take that loss. That's not my point. I just think this ban has no positive effects whatsoever and I'm just hoping people realize that if true.