This is the same logic that allows right wing ideologues to become legitimate sources of information. A causal interest in a topic is NOT the same as being an industry expert, and the opinions of industry experts should be weighted far heavier in our minds than people who “sound like they know what they’re talking about”.

And your logic is the same followed by government agencies when they effectively agree to regulatory capture because all of the industry experts work at this company, so why not just let the company write the rulebook? 🤔

I personally don't believe we need "industry experts" in every new, emerging type of tech to be the sole voices considered about them because that's how we largely arrived at the great enshitterment we're already experiencing.

Edit: It's really quite a baffling take (given a moment's thought) that the big problem and/or a large problem facing America is that we aren't cozy enough with "industry experts". Industry practically write the policy in this country, and the only places where we have any kind of great debate (e.g. net neutrality, encryption) is where there are conflicting industry concerns.