1162
submitted 5 months ago by boredtortoise@lemm.ee to c/world@lemmy.world

Finland's results in the European election bucked a continent-wide trend of rising support for parties on the outer fringe of right-wing politics, with the Left Alliance and the National Coalition winning big at the expense of the nationalist Finns Party.

Leftist leader Li Andersson received more votes than any other candidate has ever received in a European election.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] Aceticon@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

No.

Livre are Liberals cosplaying as Lefties.

In a genuine fight for Equality you don't go around segregating people by identities and deeming some more deserving to fight for than others because of the identity you think that they belong to: you fight for everybody who is being treated unfairly, ideally going after that which is causing greatest pain first.

Split people by the genetics they were born with and treating them differently based on that is not the path to Equality and Fairness, it's just a different kind of Inequality and Unfairness, so those doing such dividing and segregated treatment are either fighting for something else - say, "everybody should be free to do what they want with consenting adults", which is fine, but at times incompatible with the core leftwing principle of "the best possible life for the greatest number", especially when it comes to money (were the latter principle would go against the Freedom of some to accumulate as much wealth as they want), so that's not Leftwing, that's just Liberalism - or they're tribalist fad followers, who don't think when it comes to politics.

I wouldn't be surprised if Livre end up turning out to be just as much a bunch of self-serving assholes seeking "jobs for the boys" by ridding a fashionable political strain imported from elsewhere as Portugal's newest "Green Party" cosplayers, PAN, turned out to be.

[-] JimmyMcGill@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago

I’ll read your comment in more detail later but who were you talking about then?

[-] Aceticon@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

O Bloco.

If you look at the leadership they're incredibly uniform (almost all 30-somethings, from well off origins, either there because mommy or daddy were middle class leftwingers during the Fascist days - which I can respect, whilst at the same time thinking says nothing about their childrens' qualities or values - or because they're mates with such people). Unsurprisingly they all sound like betinhos (soft spoken middle-class types constantly signaling their social status in language, dress and manners) and do not at all come across as competent or even with any breadth of life experience (plenty never experienced or did anything other than Politics, a characteristic they share with people of the same age in the two mainstream political parties).

I mean, it's fine to be like that, it's just not fine when a politicial party which is supposed to fight for and represent all kinds of people is so narrow in the original social strata, age, life experience and universities frequented (including actually having frequented one) of those who lead it, and hence their way of thinking and the kind of things they're aware of, not to mention that highly uniform social environments are invariably the result of people selecting each other by similarity and friendship (i.e. cronyism) not merit, since merit comes in all shapes, forms, genders, ages and origins and hence selection by it naturally yields a lot more variety in a group.

(There are a ton of blindspots for any group of people who are highly uniform and that problem due to the uniformity in the leadership of the Block has been easilly exploited by the mainstream "leftwing" party and even the far right in Portugal in the last 2 elections)

As somebody who spent his young adult years in The Netherlands, I have very different values in terms of openness and much stricter Democratic expectations than the shit that dominates the party, were I've seen my share of systematic undemocratic behaviours and treating mechanisms meant for free and democratic choice including actual votes as nothing more than "formalities". Also, having lived and been in politics in Britain I have a keen ability to detect the parroting of the performative "leftwing" ideas from the fake leftwing wing parties there (LibDems, New Labour, equivalent to the Democrats in the US) which oh-so-often seems to be repeated by local lefties who being too unwordly to understand the context and trying to follow the fashion of the "left" in those countries, parrot neoliberal stuff they read in English-language social media.

It's very frustrating because I originally thought they were a thinking Left.

[-] JimmyMcGill@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

I’m not sure I agree

For one Bloco’s majority of votes comes from exactly the opposite of what you say they are. I.e. lower class and less educated people.

I don’t think they have the image of being “betinhos”, quite the opposite. Majority of Betos vote IL, Agrobetos somehow vote chega, and betos who lean left and actually care about social issues now vote Livre. Some of them also voted PAN but fortunately less and less.

The view I have of Bloco is that they are more on the woke warrior side and a bit too much sometimes. The whole, I am more knowledgeable than you is very present in IL and in a way also in Rui Tavares.

Catarina Martins is one of the more empathetic politicians we have in Portugal atm. The Mortagua sisters may have a well off background but they have proven their work countless times and many times outside of Bloco. Marisa Matias and José Gusmão are both almost 50 and no where close to your description of “elite”.

But I guess your opinion is just as valid. For what it’s worth I actually joined them very recently but so far haven’t seen much of anything (apart from disorganization).

[-] Aceticon@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

Maybe it was all those years outside of Portugal, but in my mind "betinhos" isn't just a certain young wannabe (or even outright) rich person (the outright being common in places like Cascais) but is more generically a middle class person from a middle class background who heavilly signals their well-off status - they're indeed two different kinds, but when it comes to the way they talk they have quite similar styles and run around with an elitist belief that they know better. Maybe it's my working class background (even though I do have a degree and am supposedly middle class myself nowadays) or some kind of hyper-sensitivity to class status signalling from having lived in the UK, but for me the well-off leftwing soft "rebels" from well-off families who behave towards working class party members in a paternalistic way are from the same branch of the tree as the other kind even though they've taken a turn to the left rather than the right.

It does make sense that the "betinhos" from the wannabe rich in the sense you seem to be thinking about vote IL since that party sells an idea of meritocracy (entirelly fake as I can tell you from having worked in the industry from were most of those "gentlemen" from IL come - Finance) which would appeal to the "not yet rich who want to believe they'll get there if they try to emulate what they think are the rich hard enough". Curiously from what I've seen when manning voting boots in Cascais for the Bloco a few elections ago, the real deal upper class "betinhos" probably vote CDS.

I've been a member of the Bloco for 4 years now, in 2 different districts and whilst I spent most of the time in the first couple of years with a "all I know is that I know nothing" posture of watching and learning, I did pay a lot of attention and used a couple of decades of experience gained abroad (in various kinds of companies and various countries) in figuring out new environments, observing how things work between people and even winding people up just to get them to say what they really think, and have seen and heard a lot of elitist and even outright anti-Democratic posture in the Bloco, including from sitting Parliamentary Members I know personnally (I've also seen good things here and there and don't actually think most people there have bad intentions, they're mainly out of ignorance and lack of self-awareness behaving in ways that are elitist, self-serving - not in a greedy way but in an interpret things in ways that avoid accepting that they too sometimes are *gasp* wrong - really reactive, inconsistent and lacking a broader vision, and even with ouright anti-Democratic behaviours).

I've also seen some ridiculous fake leftie stuff from the membership: in one congress I went to most of the speeches from members were of the "we the [some group] want/need X, Y, Z", which is my eyes is just greed disguised as "for the group", whilst the "for the common good" kind of stuff (or at least the stuff worring about groups other than those one is in) were a lot less than what I (naivelly?) expected in a congress of a real Leftwing Party.

I don't know about the class of the voters of the Bloco, all I know is that the leadership of the party at the highest level are all degree-holding people and even the District leadership in the District I live in which contains large blue collar areas and hence an unusally high number of blue collar worker members (still a minority), only a tiny handful of the District Leadership are blue collar.

Maybe it's a wider Portuguese phenomenon, but the tendency of many Middle Class people to think they know better even in subjects they know nothing about and use haughty dialetics to basically bully the less well educated or just ignoring them whilst faking listenning to them rather than really listenning and taking it in what a Working Class person says, even on subjects that the Working Class person does not better, is alive and well in the Bloco, were IMHO I think it's unnacceptable (acceptable in the pro-Elite rightwing, not in a supposedly pro-everybody leftwing party).

This social blindness manifests in some ridiculous ways sometimes: I remember one election where the national leadership (who, by the way, don't seem to listen to anybody else that people from Lisbon and Porto, to the point that councils in the same district felt ignored) sent us a black middle class woman to go campaigning in a poor neigbourhood which had lots of people who were born in Africa and became Portuguese nationals or their children, and she behaved incredibly "middle class woman" with this kind of bland "we understand your problem" talk whilst not really properly empathising with the concerns of those people, whilst the person amongst us really empathising (mainly by getting progressivelly angry at the shit that was being done to them) and coming up with ways to try and help them within the power of a party that had all of one seat in the local assembly was a local guy who didn't at all look like them but had been in some pretty bad State highschools whilst growing up and really knew how life could be for somebody from such neighbourhoods.

(The funny bit was that the lady herself once elected was pretty decent as member of Parliament, she just wasn't at all representative of the people those who put her forward for meeting and seemingly represent, with quite extraordinary socially-blindness only seemed to see as "ethnics" hence they "matched them by ethnicity" - you need to be incredibly socially-deluded to see poor people and think what matters the most is their skin color).

For me the collapse of the vote on the Bloco in the last couple of years as the mainstream parties started falling (which one would expect was a prime time for a leftwing alternative voice to gain votes) did not surprise me in the least given all that I saw from the inside including some interesting talks with my local member of Parliament once I moved to a District capital.

Maybe the party can be pushed and prodded to become more like this Finnish party seems to be, though judging by how self-isolated, elitist and Party-Headquarters centric the current leadership are and how little they listen to the rest (except when an election comes and they need people to go around campaigning, which is when they suddenly remember to tour the "countryside" and talk to the members, though even those "listening" tours are very much in a "important people and little people" structure rather than "open discussion") I don't think it will happen without the old guard - who were the ones who chose to give way to this handpicked "new generation" - cut their legs off.

[-] JimmyMcGill@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago

Why are you still a member? It seems like you aren’t having a good time.

[-] Aceticon@lemmy.world 1 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

I haven't totally lost hope yet.

Also it's not like most people in the party don't have good intentions, it's mostly a problem of ineptitude, the unfortunate Portuguese tendency to "make it up as you go" and not being quite as strict as I am when it comes to Democratic principles of free and fair choice, openness and the nature of being a representative for others.

A broadenning of the kinds of people that end up leading the party and a replacing of the culture of self-deluded ignorant elitism at the top with one of openness might shift the politics of the party into a more aware and hence more representative and even more competent track.

If there is one thing I've concluded from my experience of living in multiple countries and even being involved in politics in some is that variety and some amount of flux are the best things to have in Democracy: it's when people sit too long in places of power and surround themselves with others like them (or, worse, Yes men) that you get problems - there is no leadership that doesn't turn to shit once it's had a decade or two constantly at the top.

(Note that in this party at the moment the leadership is not a person, it's a group. This was especially true during the time of Catarina who internally was very open and clear about only wanting to be a spokesperson, not "the boss").

I very much doubt the culture of cronyism can be replaced by something more meritocratic (as that's a general problem in Portuguese society rather than specific to that party), but merelly variety will at least lead to more ways of thinking about and approaching everything because more varied backgrouns bring more varied outlooks and approaches to figuring out how to achieve the kind of society people in that party generally want to have (even if they seldom know how to even start to get there).

this post was submitted on 10 Jun 2024
1162 points (98.9% liked)

World News

39112 readers
930 users here now

A community for discussing events around the World

Rules:

Similarly, if you see posts along these lines, do not engage. Report them, block them, and live a happier life than they do. We see too many slapfights that boil down to "Mom! He's bugging me!" and "I'm not touching you!" Going forward, slapfights will result in removed comments and temp bans to cool off.

We ask that the users report any comment or post that violate the rules, to use critical thinking when reading, posting or commenting. Users that post off-topic spam, advocate violence, have multiple comments or posts removed, weaponize reports or violate the code of conduct will be banned.

All posts and comments will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. This means that some content that violates the rules may be allowed, while other content that does not violate the rules may be removed. The moderators retain the right to remove any content and ban users.


Lemmy World Partners

News !news@lemmy.world

Politics !politics@lemmy.world

World Politics !globalpolitics@lemmy.world


Recommendations

For Firefox users, there is media bias / propaganda / fact check plugin.

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/media-bias-fact-check/

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS