On the other other hand, we already had the option of choosing Bluetooth headphones back when most phones still offered headphones jacks.

Truth is, there are obviously pros and cons of each, but it just sucks that we no longer have the choice without jumping through extra hoops.

And the noise cancelling/amplification is something wired headphones probably would never do, and they aren't more expensive than ear buds, unless you got the cheapest ear buds (that probably sounded like shit and had cords that would fray within months of use), oh and if you used them at all "actively" the cords would eventually wear out even in expensive models. I've got a 20$pair of ear buds from 3 years ago(wanted to make sure I wouldn't lose them before investing in expensive ones, now I don't actually like my expensive ones except for airplanes, and still use my cheapos). Oh and you couldn't be more than 3 feet from your phone if it was charging, and you couldn't fast forward, rewind, play/pause (if you had a great pair it had a volume control, that didn't actually change the volume, just added resistance to the signal).

Ask my wife, I was one of the biggest sticks in the mud about losing my headphone jack and changing over to Bluetooth, but since I made the change, I've found plenty of reasons to be happy with it. I still miss my old phones built in infrared blaster though. And easily replaceable battery. There were some neat things you could do with the aux jack (credit card reader), and there was some convenience to having things corded together (especially if you're absent minded) but it's not as rosey as many would insist it was.

The rose tinted glasses people use when looking back (car technology, streaming being worse than cable, the Internet sucking (though much better arguments for this one)) is really a burr in my side.