I really liked Amnesia when it was first released. Also, penumbra is really good, too. I always recommend them to people! I think maybe I've desensitized myself to frictional games development style because I don't tend to find their games scary anymore. Their latest game did have me tense for a bit, but it quickly wore off as I got used to it :(

I'm chasing that high of getting scared haha. I'm not sure what to do. I figure at this point I just need to play everything I can get my hands on