82
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 21 Oct 2025
82 points (96.6% liked)
Not the Onion
2859 readers
20 users here now
For true stories that are so ridiculous, that you could have sworn it was an !theonion worthy story.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
I heard the interview. The story about the tattoo seemed genuine and he chose to release the video himself. There's loads of skull and crossbones imagery in various US military insignia. I'm willing to believe him.
Edit: Looks like he got it covered up, so happy now?
https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/maine-senate-candidategraham-platner-covered-tattoo-resembled-nazi/story?id=126774352
Yeah lets give the guy that did 4 tours in Iraq as a marine and one in Afghanistan as a blackwater merc the benefit of the doubt lol
If there's ever a comment defending Nazis on lemmy, you can bet it'll be .world user 90% of the time.
Hey now give shits.fullon.fash and sonazi.xyz some credit too!
it was actually 3 tours in iraq and one in blackwater. Idk if all the tours were marine i think he might've bene in the army too.
There are lots of types of skulls and crossbones used in many contexts, but his is specifically the SS-Totenkopf insignia used from 1934 to 1945.
It seems very implausible that, as he claims, nobody ever told him this before now.
And he obviously chose to release the video himself as damage control only after he knew it was coming out anyway.
That link has like 7 different variations of the skull and crossbones that the Nazis used and that covers basically every usage by anyone ever. I just don't buy that he's a closed Nazi and it never came up in all his Reddit shitposting.
Did you see the video or just listen to it? In case not, here is a link to the part of the podcast where they play the video showing the tattoo.
But one is by far the most well known; you may remember it from Mitchell and Webb's Are we the baddies?
I watched the video. I'm not arguing that it is the same skull used by the Nazi SS. I'm arguing that specific skull wasn't created by the Nazis (here it is on an 18th century pirate flag)
and it wasn't used last by the Nazis (here it is on a US special forces patch used in Vietnam) 
.
The US military has used all sorts of eagles, swords, crosses, skulls, double lightning bolts, etc over the years that were also used by Nazis at some point. I just don't think it is reasonable to say he's a Nazi based on this tattoo alone in the absolute absence of any other evidence of any sort.
There's just no way the US military allowed Nazi symbology to proliferate amongst its ranks. That's certainly never happened before. We're the good guys /s
It could be that, or it could also be that the Nazis copied some of this stuff from the US. They admired our treatment of black people and borrowed a lot from us.
No, totenkopf was symbol used in XIX century by Prussian hussars. They were pretty badass so it spread a little in different forms in the region, but it only made a world career by being symbol of SS.
The pirate flag I posted earlier was from the XVIII century. The skull and crossbones in general was used by pirates from the XVIII century onward. In general it was used in Europe since the late middle ages, originating in Spain. The Hussars were just the first military regiment to officially use it.
The skull of Adam at the foot of the Cross: detail from a Crucifixion by Fra Angelico, 1435
Here is a grave in Ireland, likely from around 1730 with the symbol.
And I'm just sticking to depictions with the left facing 1/4 turn that the SS most often used. I guess my point is that the association of the symbol with death far elipses it's association with the SS.
You seem to consistently and deliberately confuse specific design used by SS with any usage of similar symbol through the ages.
There is no point in arguing this anymore because the tattoo that started this whole thing has been altered to a non offensive design.
that one is an entirely dissimilar skull and cross bones
that one is 100% intentionally the SS-Totenkopf
I'm not saying he necessarily secretly considers himself a Nazi, but he does have an unambiguously Nazi tattoo and his explicit claim that he was totally clueless about its meaning for 18 years is simply not believable (especially in light of other evidence, like his reddit posts defending other solders' double lightning bolt tattoos).
Yea, it is unambiguously a Nazi tattoo. It is also just as accurate to say it is a pirate tattoo or a Vietnam era special forces tattoo. Personally, I just don't see it as automatically damning in itself.