152
CAPTCHAs have been broken for quite a while now.
Google’s reCAPTCHA in particular is terrible and I fail it about half the time trying to guess what it thinks counts as part of a bicycle or not.
I always found it kind of ironic that the tool used to prevent robot traffic, CAPTCHA, is also used as a data source train robots.
I don't want you getting through this lock, so I'm going to sit you down and meticulously teach you how to get through this lock...
What's even more ironic is that we basically don't need human data anymore to create AI that classify objects or detect their boundaries. With algorithms like DINO we don't even need labeled data at all, you just throw images at it and it learns on its own.
Google spent all this time collecting data through CAPTCHAs to train AI and now it might as well be obsolete.
They are broken because AI is better at solving these capthcas than humans. They are only stopping those spammers who can't afford a gpu to break these catchas
Have you de-Googled or something? They only really nail you when you don't have a signed-in Google account with real-world web usage, particularly if your connection originates from a flagged IP.
Oh yes, how dare I visit a website without letting Google track me. Better block the user with a fake test in the name of security.
Some VPNs will definitely trigger reCaptcha, even if signed on to Google. I just have to hop over to another IP and suddenly everything is fine again.
I've noticed I get the stupid recaptha way more since I swapped to Firefox. Even though I'm logged in to a Google account.
I get it a lot when I'm using our work VPN (which shows up as an AWS IP address). I guess if you're using a VPN or a less reputable ISP you'll probably get stung more often.
I've been liking cloudflare more and more over the years. They've been taking some genuinely big steps towards a more free, open, and private internet; them, alongside the Mozilla Foundation. Two big thumbs up :)
I've been running pihole for years, but recently put cloudflared behind it to translate all standard DNS traffic to DoH traffic after filtering but before leaving the LAN. Now I just gotta find a good way to implement DoH from client>pihole and devices can start using ECH while still receiving DNS adblock. This will make 100% of the traffic leaving my network encrypted :) (if the client wants it to be at least)
I get why people dislike them, because they definitely are a very overwhelming monopoly. But despite that, they really provide very essential tools that are very easily accessible and free. I do like them as a company, so I haven't been too worried by the fact they are a huge monopoly that dominates a big portion of the web. They've handled the responsibility pretty well.
Google started this way too, just wait.
I've been running pihole for years, but recently put cloudflared behind it to translate all standard DNS traffic to DoH traffic after filtering but before leaving the LAN.
I'd like to do this with my Pi-hole too. How did you do it?
Proton has introduced their own version of captcha as well — blog post
Sadly it doesn’t seem like anyone can use it on their own site
Yeah and I don't think they will release it for public use anytime soon
I personally think cloudflare is a blessing in disguise.
I would much rather see a whole bunch of companies competing than a single company controlling everything
So what type of challenge do you get when it doesn't think you're human then?
Terminator noises
Me likes cloudflare
this post was submitted on 14 Oct 2023
152 points (98.1% liked)
Sysadmin
7717 readers
206 users here now
A community dedicated to the profession of IT Systems Administration
No generic Lemmy issue posts please! Posts about Lemmy belong in one of these communities:
!lemmy@lemmy.ml
!lemmyworld@lemmy.world
!lemmy_support@lemmy.ml
!support@lemmy.world
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS