13
universal IDs for threadiverse items (re kbin-core #635) (kbin.social)
submitted 1 year ago by density@kbin.social to c/kbinMeta@kbin.social
7 comments fedilink hide all child comments

I am not sure what is correct to put in kbin-core/issues without cluttering it up with somewhat speculative requests. I have no idea how to implement this or whether it is possible. So I will post here?

This is a response to issue
#635 - Editor support for autocompletion when a user types /m/, /c/, /u/, or @

@garrettw said:

After all of this I'm left with the distinct impression that a standardized link format is needed across the fediverse for any fediverse content.

I keep wishing for UUIDs or hashes or an internal link shortener or permalink something.

These are the same post on different instances:

It would be nice if it would have a unique ID like e3d14d6c-28d7-11ee-be56-0242ac120002 across the *verse. I can't be the first person to think of this right? Why is ity either not a good idea, or not a viable idea?

I imagine 2 variations. I am not attached to any of the particulars... Just spitballing. What do you think?

  1. /local/uuid

/local/e3d14d6c-28d7-11ee-be56-0242ac120002 - this link would bring the user to the post on the instance where you are viewing it.

So if someone writes in a comment:

check out [this post](/local/e3d14d6c-28d7-11ee-be56-0242ac120002)!

and you are viewing it on beehaw, it renders like this:

<p>check out <a href="https://beehaw.org/post/6759290">this post</a>!</p>

if you are viewing it on kbin.social, it renders like this:

<p>check out <a href="https://kbin.social/m/firefox@fedia.io/t/237162">this post</a>!</p>
  1. /orig/uuid

On the other hand we need a way to link to the particular item as it appears "originally". To do this, you could write:

check out [this post](/orig/e3d14d6c-28d7-11ee-be56-0242ac120002)!

And irrespective of where you are looking at it, it will render like this:

<p>check out <a href="https://fedia.io/m/firefox/t/132144">this post</a>!</p>

I am not 100% sure if the correct behaviour for this is to link to the community home instance or the poster's home instance? I went with community home but maybe there is argument for the other way, or for both.

top 7 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[-] mack123@kbin.social 3 points 1 year ago

This would be very useful. I would argue for the universal link to go to the user's home instance, where the user should already be logged in and able to interact with the post. That is if the user has a default set. Otherwise the magazine's home instance makes sense for a unknown user.

It would be a core feature on activity pub itself though, with limited use on kbin.

[-] density@kbin.social 2 points 1 year ago

It would be a core feature on activity pub itself though, with limited use on kbin.

Oh man that sounds like something that's Not Gonna Happen. :(

There must be some reason why this is impractical/implausible or it would already be in there.

[-] mack123@kbin.social 2 points 1 year ago

I am so new to this that I cannot say. It may be area for the many apps under development to shine.

[-] trynn@kbin.social 1 points 1 year ago

The impractical/implausible reason is likely because different groups of people are writing the different fediverse software and have different opinions about how objects are identified in their software. ActivityPub already requires objects to have unique IDs, so this isn't a protocol issue. But good luck getting every single developer for every single fediverse application to agree on one way to internally represent data in their apps. That's just never going to happen for a variety of reasons.

[-] density@kbin.social 1 points 1 year ago

It's true! I actually took a wee peek into the ActivityPub standard earlier and saw that the ID thing is already there like you say. Which I guess is the URLs as posted above?

So that part is done & dusted I guess. :) The part that would remain now would be to make a convention to transform markdown. Markdown is already being transformed.

Does the threadiverse need to maintain perfect compatibility with the rest of the activity pub fediverse? For me, just kbin and lemmy being roughly on the same page would be great. But maybe my viewpoint is too narrow and self centred.

[-] elmicha@kbin.social 2 points 1 year ago

I don't understand from where the user gets the uuid. If the links are rendered with these localized urls, how does a user know the uuid that he could post?

[-] density@kbin.social 1 points 1 year ago

if you look under this comment or any post you see text that says "more". there are 2 similar options there: "copy url" and "copy url to fediverse".

In my proposal, items along the lines of "copy local url" and "copy unique url" would be added to the above.

I think the nomenclature "local url" and "unique url" needs some work tbh.

this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2023
13 points (100.0% liked)

/kbin meta

2 readers
1 users here now

Magazine dedicated to discussions about the kbin itself. Provide feedback, ask questions, suggest improvements, and engage in conversations related to the platform organization, policies, features, and community dynamics. ---- * Roadmap 2023 * m/kbinDevlog * m/kbinDesign

founded 1 year ago