For anyone else who was curious like me, there are manual steps required for existing installs to use the plasma login manager:
**Manual changes for existing users:** KDE Plasma users with SDDM can now migrate to Plasma-Login-Manager. Please run: sudo pacman -Syu plasma-login-manager sudo systemctl disable sddm sudo systemctl enable plasmalogin sudo pacman -R sddm-kcm cachyos-themes-sddm sddm After that you can use in Plasma Settings under the KCM “Apply Settings”.