☝️🤓📋❌❎🙅‍♂️👎👎👎

You just ignore anything that gives you cognitive dissonance. You have no idea what I mean by "narrative framing that supports genocide" because that narrative is your entire reality as a liberal zionist yourself.

Israel is going to lose the same way "South Vietnam" and SA apartheid did.

We're not talking about war with Iran lmao, but about their ties to PFLP, Hamas, Hezbollah, Ansarallah. Hamas is not losing to Israel yet. Hezbollah will heat things up more depending on how endangered they are.

😱😱😱😱😱

Half a million settlers already disagreed with you like two weeks in. All I gotta do is point out the internal inconsistencies. Klein can't even do that. She's a fucking hack who writes entire books based off wordplay.

Haha, you didn't want to admit you think that, did you? Just wait around and see.

Nonviolent protests and just boycotting is extremely anemic when you also continue to support the narrative framing abt Hamas atrocities that is used to continue the genocide & support the existence of the rogue nuclear state that perpetrates them.

Saying "yes you're right but please be merciful" impresses you because you love rhetoric. Screw you!

Everyone even moderately familiar with this issue understands that Israel is the largest recipient of US foreign aid and that the US has always provided political cover internationally.

You skipped over everything else about the content of that aid and how it is used. So did she. She just acknowledges it and moves on as if it's barely important.

Okay keep doing this bazinga shit if you want I will just come back tonight with an essay

Purity test lmao. Not even. I'm just clarifying what she means to you.

"direct action and bds" to do what mfer? to make them tone down the currently unsustainable militarism of the occupation. not bds and direct action to END ISRAEL. which is what is coming next if they don't tone it down. she's trying to save israel, just like bernie. they're all monsters. god damn the liberals to hell

Well, I'm willing to expound on it. A few points off the top of my head.

we will need to talk about the difference between Occupy Wall St. direct action and BDS direct action and actual Vietcong-esque resistance against the occupation

playing resistance olympics, portraying al aqsa flood as being disorganized and fruitless, hezbollah & iran inaction as a betrayal, while simultaneously criticizing iranian funding of ansarallah. calling ansarallah "houthis". implying they are just attacking shipping instead of targeting Eilat & have triggered a capital strike in response

acts like Israeli tactics are a military response to Hamas war crimes rather than war crimes in response to resistance against military occupation

again, does not put too fine a point on the deliberate targeting of civilians and military ineffectiveness. the unsustainability of massive US aid which has even resulted in Ukraine pullback

acts like those military responses are effectively rooting out hamas by not pointing out they are an attempt at genocide & are taking heavy losses

treats israeli settlers as blameless civilians who don't deserve to be pelted with rockets (false, go look at videos of them cheering on bombing of Gaza, they deserve to die)

supports evidence-free zionist claims of atrocities

What do you think she should have included that would have convinced US lawmakers to end the special relationship with Israel?

???? The insanity of acting like we all just have to make the right statements to solve this. I'm talking about the way she frames the genocide and how people who take up this framing lack a solution.

Literally cursory mention of steady flow of arms is enough for you?? That could mean guns and vests lmao. This article would have been lame in October. It may as well be 20 years old.

Sure I'll write a full length response this evening since you clearly see no problem with someone decrying actual military responses to this horror as war crimes of their own and not putting too fine a point on the babies Israel is disintegrating daily.

Anyone treating this as a normal war is useless. You've all done less than nothing, you've tried to delegitimize the only actual direct action which has harmed Israel's economy.

I have strongly condemned Hamas's targeting of civilians as war crimes, in my own writing and in org statements.

October 28

https://nitter.net/NaomiAKlein/status/1718320141539418619#m

Disingenuous bullshitting. The shock doctrine also sucks people just recommend it because she appears on podcasts (who know her from Occupy Wall St. and aren't reading types, prone to complaining about having to speak into a mic two hours a month)

Now that they're running into difficulties and losing control of areas they "captured" suddenly negotiating a ceasefire becomes acceptable to libs

I really don't like the whole "why can't we all just be friends I condemn violence on both sides" shit even when it comes in the form of appealing to nonexistent Zionist compassion