Here's mine:

• Elvis Presley - Blue Christmas
• Elvis Presley - White Christmas
• Elvis Presley - Santa Claus Is Back In Town
• Elvis Presley - I'll Be Home for Christmas
• Elvis Presley - If Every Day Was Like Christmas
• Elvis Presley - Here Comes Santa Claus (Right Down Santa Claus Lane)
• Elvis Presley - Santa Bring My Baby Back (To Me)
• *NSYNC - Home for Christmas
• *NSYNC - Under My Tree
• *NSYNC - I Never Knew the Meaning of Christmas
• *NSYNC - Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays
• *NSYNC - The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire)
• *NSYNC - I Guess It's Christmas Time
• *NSYNC - All I Want Is You (This Christmas)
• *NSYNC - The First Noel
• *NSYNC - In Love on Christmas
• *NSYNC - It's Christmas
• *NSYNC - O Holy Night - A Cappella
• *NSYNC - Love's in Our Hearts on Christmas Day
• *NSYNC - The Only Gift
• *NSYNC - Kiss Me at Midnight
• Louis Prima; Joe "Wingy" Manone - What Will Santa Claus Say? (When He Finds Everybody Swingin') - 78 rpm Version
• Big Bad Voodoo Daddy - Christmastime In Tinseltown
• The Jackson 5 - Santa Claus Is Coming To Town
• James Brown - Soulful Christmas
• Chuck Berry - Run Rudolph Run

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MeBsHfJ5LAxXYU9rDYla8

PS. My (at the time) preteen daughter had a lot of input on this list. However, it has maintained its integrity through the years, and is what we use currently.