188
What is jury nullification and what does it mean for Luigi Mangione’s defense? (edition.cnn.com)
submitted 17 hours ago by geneva_convenience@lemmy.ml to c/usa@lemmy.ml
33 comments fedilink hide all child comments

Jury nullification is the term for when a jury declines to convict a defendant despite overwhelming evidence of guilt. This can be a form of civil disobedience, a political statement against a specific law, or a show of empathy and support to the defendant.

“It’s not a legal defense sanctioned under the law,” said Cheryl Bader, associate professor of law at Fordham School of Law. “It’s a reaction by the jury to a legal result that they feel would be so unjust or morally wrong that they refuse to impose it, despite what the law says.”

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] marsara9@lemmy.world 3 points 15 hours ago

Jury nullification is the term for when a jury declines to convict a defendant despite overwhelming evidence of guilt.

Jury refers to the twelve. If any one could nullify them it would say juror.

If they can’t all agree, this is called a hung jury, and the Judge will have to declare a mistrial. A mistrial does not mean that the case is over. After a mistrial, the prosecutor can choose to try the case again.

I assume you read the last word of that sentence? If there's a hung jury then prosecutors can just bring it to trial again, as there was no jeopardy with the first case, as the jury never reached a unanimous decision.

So jury nullification is equal to a not guilty verdict. It's just that the jury has deemed that while technically guilty they shouldn't be punished for what they did. With jury nullification the defendant can't be tried again, compared to a mistrial where they can.

[-] Josey_Wales@lemm.ee 1 points 13 hours ago* (last edited 13 hours ago)

If all vote not guilty it’s called an acquittal. If that happens, despite overwhelming evidence of guilt, it is jury nullification ending in an acquittal. If a mistrial happens, meaning the jury cannot reach a verdict, despite overwhelming evidence of guilt, it is jury nullification ending in a mistrial.

Source: I have been a public defender in NYC for 15 years.

this post was submitted on 11 Jan 2025
188 points (99.5% liked)

United States | News & Politics

7378 readers
703 users here now

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
pangyuehung@lemmy.ml
yogthos@lemmy.ml