247
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 18 Aug 2023
247 points (99.6% liked)
chapotraphouse
13484 readers
910 users here now
Banned? DM Wmill to appeal.
No anti-nautilism posts. See: Eco-fascism Primer
Vaush posts go in the_dunk_tank
Dunk posts in general go in the_dunk_tank, not here
Don't post low-hanging fruit here after it gets removed from the_dunk_tank
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
Ah, the "double genocide" theorists. What a delightful bunch of historical revisionists. It's like they took a drunken joyride through the annals of history and crashed straight into the "Bad Takes" tree. Comparing the Soviet Union to the Nazis? Might as well compare a stubbed toe to a decapitation.
And you can bet your ass that most of these armchair historians haven’t even read a book on the topic. It's all surface-level, cherry-picked facts with more holes than a block of Swiss cheese. It's historical interpretation with the depth of a kiddie pool. Dive in, and you're gonna crack your head open.
Honestly, it’s a disservice to the real complexities of history. But nuance, for these folks, seems to be a concept as elusive as a unicorn riding a Bigfoot. The actual victims, the real-life people affected by these events, deserve better than to be pawns in someone’s misguided, edgy take on history.
So, to those pushing the "double genocide" theory: Maybe spend less time trying to stir the pot with wild equivalences and more time, I dunno, actually understanding the depth and breadth of historical events. And for the love of God, please get some new reading glasses, because your perspective is blurrier than a foggy window smeared with bullshit.
Sure they've read a book, Gulag Archipelago
Don't even get me started on that capitalist propaganda piece known as The Gulag Archipelago...
So, Solzhenitsyn decides to pen this mammoth of a book, which is basically a relentless bitch-fest about the Soviet prison system. Look, buddy, I get it – gulags ain't no five-star resorts. But what's with the endless whining? It's like listening to someone complain about a bad Tetris game when the blocks just won't fit right. Only this time, the blocks are tales of sorrow and despair, and, boy, does Solzhenitsyn lay it on thick!
This dude's blending memoir, history, and his personal gripes into a cocktail of anti-communist drivel. It's like trying to make vodka out of moldy potatoes and rainwater. Sure, it might get you drunk, but you'll wish you never took a sip!
Oh, and the size of this thing! It's like Solzhenitsyn's trying to outdo Tolstoy in the "lengthy Russian novels that no one actually finishes" competition. It's the literary equivalent of a speedrunner trying to complete a glitchy game with no save points.
And, let's talk ideology. This guy's so hell-bent on painting communism as the devil's own ideology that he basically ignores any nuanced discussion. It's like playing a game where the only strategy is to spam the attack button and hope for the best. Bro, maybe take a step back and see the bigger picture. Not everything's black and white, you know?
So, while "The Gulag Archipelago" might serve as a wet dream for anti-communist folks, it's like a broken cartridge to me – full of glitches, bias, and a one-sided perspective. If you're looking for a balanced take on history, maybe look elsewhere. If you're just here for the dramatic horror stories and want to bash communism, then, by all means, dive into this ocean of capitalist tears. But don't say I didn't warn ya.
I'd also say most of his numbers are utterly wrong and overstated, because he used the stats of the atypical political prisoner gulags he was in (which weren'teven typical for the average poltitical prisoner.)
We know this because after the USSR fell we got access to the real stats.