I agree with your analysis, point I was making above that the situation like that person defending themselves with int he residence has any and all mean available to them up to and including killing the perp until the perp retreats.

Concept that victim can clearly sort out degree of force necessary to stop the intruder is naive. which is what the commenter is shilling in this thread.

If the person retreats outside, yeah no shit you can't kill them for funsies... nobody argued that as he seems to think.