I feel like I have been expressing the other perspective in great detail, but I also don't feel like you have meaningfully engaged with that perspective and have instead focused on my personal beliefs. Perhaps that's an effort to protect your own beliefs, for fear that such engagement might cause you to question things that you consider fundamental to your understanding of the world and your self identity. I can't say for sure, but I can say that I have personally been in that position and felt that way.

Even if we assume that there is an objectively moral decision in this scenario, we can never know with absolute certainty without asking God directly. Even the wisest scholars of what we do have of God's word disagree on its interpretation, which leaves humanity with a lot of ambiguity.

I always enjoy discussing philosophy, and agree that this has been an enjoyable discussion. I wish you well, I hope you have a wonderful day, and I hope to engage in similarly enjoyable conversations with you again in the future.