394
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 05 Mar 2026
394 points (99.7% liked)
Memes of Production
1594 readers
391 users here now
Seize the Memes of Production
An international (English speaking) socialist Lemmy community free of the “ML” influence of instances like lemmy.ml and lemmygrad. This is a place for undogmatic shitposting and memes from a progressive, anti-capitalist and truly anti-imperialist perspective, regardless of specific ideology.
Rules:
Be a decent person.
No racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, zionism/nazism, and so on.
Other Great Communities:
founded 4 months ago
MODERATORS
Compare how much environmental damage is done by anarchist societies versus governed societies.
It's illegal for us to defend ourselves.
It's impressive how they can both destroy the environment and also not exist.
Putting words in /u/paultimate14@lemmy.world 's mouth, I'm guessing they are referring to Libertarian de-regulation type stuff, where we have seen that Capitalists will always choose to pollute or do other external harms as long as they don't pay the cost. That's not the same as Anarchism, of course, but as someone not well read on either ideology it feels like the outcome would be similar.
"As someone who has no idea what I'm talking about, this is what I would think would happen." Is what you and basically everyone else shitting on anarchism is saying. You are all talking about anarchism like capitalism would still exist, which it wouldnt. "Anarcho"-capitalism is what most of you are talking about and it is almost universally ostracized by the anarchist community.
It is nearly impossible to talk to non-anarchists about anarchism I have found because it feels like yall can only look at one part of the picture at a time, and have then forget what you were just looking at when you change focus. Genuinely just read theory and learn about actual experiments into anarchism. I recommend "At the Cafe" by Malatesta, and the documentary "Living in Utopia" on Zoe Baker's youtube channel. Those are what took me from being a communist to an anarcho-communist. "Conquest of Bread" by Kropotkin is also a great start. But I genuinely feel like it is impossible to argue with non-anarchists about anarchists unless they actually understand what anarchism is and the logic behind it. Something that can't be properly outlined in a meme or comment thread.
Chief, I only suggested what I thought the other person meant. I didn't make any statements of my own on the subject in question.
I am actually reading Kropotkin just now and I've perused the FAQ that is often posted here, but I'm happy for your other recommendations. I'm not sure of my specific leftist identity yet, but that's something I'm working on.
Almost everyone in the world has lived under capitalism their whole lives, and the only other major economic philosophy we westerners really learn about in school is feudalism. It's only natural that they (we) don't immediately grasp other systems of living. Thinking about Anarchism or Communism or Socialism etc as an alternative in the abstract is one thing, but it's not strange to me that that it's easier for the student to think about one piece of society at a time. By default I think that would be by comparison to the familiar system.
I wrote too much again - a common problem for me.
Anyway, just chiming in to empathize but suggest patience for the 99% of humans that haven't put as much thought into economic and political systems as you have.
Have a good one, or don't. I don't claim any authority over you! Lol.
I apologize for coming off as a agitated. Its hard to read a lot of these comments and not come away feeling that way. I am super happy to hear you are reading and educating yourself, and apologize for interpreting your comment the way I did. It is hard to keep track of who says what and that is where my confusion began.
I agree that socialism/communism is already a leap for people to understand as it breaks away from everything they have ever known, and anarchism is even worse in that regard. My frustration comes from the lack of good faith from most people when arguing in the first place. I can be patient with ignorance. I have a much harder time being patient with arrogance (which ironically ends up making me respond arrogantly). Like I said in another comment, it often feels like arguing with anti-vaccers or MAGAs because they both argue in bad faith and from a place of ignorance. Pair that with seeing it every day in almost every comment thread related to anarchism and it becomes very hard to not become bitter.
This is all to say I appreciate your response and I am sorry for the way I reacted to your comment. You are here in good faith and I let the negativity assume you weren't.
Totally get it! I didn't and don't take any offense, just sort of got caught in the crossfire this time. I don't have many opportunities to talk to sealions, or maybe I am just bad at detecting them. I have no doubt that that would get frustrating.
I know I'm ignorant on this and many other topics, but I'm slowly chipping away at some of the edges. I've seen a lot that feels right in Aism, Sism, and Cism, but they can't ALL be right about everything! I think I would most benefit from a more formal process of thinking about the kind of world I want to see and which ideas might bridge that gap but it's hard to find the time alongside actually living on this stupid rock.
Cheers! LLAP
Be sure those societies are reduced to almost no people, usually in lands that are deficient in natural resources in the first place.
Just look up for a counter-example. The Earth's atmosphere is full of space junk now because for decades no regulatory body had the balls to tell private companies not to leave their shit up there.
Your issue is once again with capitalism, not anarchism
Dude is effectively arguing that capitalism is a natural phenomenon that emerged from human interaction. Itd be funny if it weren’t so sad
Another failure of the education system to put on the board lol
There is a regulatory body; if you try to defend everyone from these private companies, then the police will arrest you. The regulation protects them from us, but not vice versa.
Ironically, space junk doesn't happen in a vacuum. 😜