Im picking which ever ends in the complete destruction of the German State nerd

The lib that cooked up this hypothetical probably meant atonement like in a "oh he's nice and so sad and docile now ahaha" kinda way but in reality it would probably involve him trying to hand Germany to the communists and helping them hunt down every last nazi.

That being said, if killing him with a magic button fucks up operation paperclip because none of the nazis want to be publicly known about so they don't get button-killed that could do some real good too.

That one's complicated. I feel like letting him live would just result in him being killed anyways and kinda nullify the benefits.

Figuring out how to use this hypothetical to fuck over nazism as a whole is wayyyyy more interesting than the lame-ass moralizing it was originally doing.