13
What was your experience with graduate school?
(beehaw.org)
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de~
I've had talks with a few PhD's and a few masters and bachelor's in mechanical, electrical, and chemical engineering. Both in my current industry and at my university.
I am not doing a Ph.D, so take my comment with a large grain of salt. But the consensus I've gotten from those I've talked to about specifically engineering disciplines is:
The trap I've had described to me is that Ph.D's often become over qualified for typical industry entry-level positions, and the number of Ph.D specific postions much narrower and specialized, making job seeking after graduation actually harder than if you simply got a normal bachelor's with one summer internship. Of course once you get in your salary will be much higher- offset by some degree by the extra 100k in student loans you'll likely have.
Ph.D's specialize in much narrower fields than undergrads, so lateral mobility is reduced once you're "set" in a specific field and industry. It's also incredibly difficult to complete compared to undergrad, and will require a ton more of your time- time that could have been spent developing earning potential and a normal life.
I know it's definitely not for me- I don't even know if I could survive long enough mentally to go through a master's program. But your mileage may vary, of course, depending on where you want to take your life.
Yeah I find most of this to be similar to what I’ve heard so that’s good confirmation, thank you.
The reason I’m considering it now is that: 1. I believe it will be applicable to industry and will raise my initial pay and work out in the long run. 2. I don’t want to work through a masters. 3. It will only take me 1 year to do it. And 4. I have a way to pay for it so I expect it to accrue very minimal debt. I have about $25k debt from my bachelors but I expect not much more to come from my masters from scholarships/assistant for a professor.
So I’m viewing this as more of a deal, I wouldn’t consider a masters if any one of these things weren’t the case probably.
Complete in only a year? I've never heard of doctorate programs running less than 2 to 3 years in the engineering world.
Still, it sounds like you've done the necessary planning and have a career path lined out for it. If that's the case, fuck it. Go for it.