For Palestinians in Gaza, the most urgent daily task is the search for water. “Obtaining water has become like prospecting for gold,” explains H., a writer with We Are Not Numbers, “and whoever finds drinkable water is considered wealthy."
Last Sunday, the Israeli ambassador to the United Nations insisted “there was not a ‘humanitarian crisis’ in Gaza despite the reported shortages of fuel, water and medical supplies in the territory[.]”
I’m a Jewish American who mentors young adult Gazan writers through a program called We Are Not Numbers (WANN). Or, at least, I did before October 7. Since Israel started bombing the territory and cut off most communications, I can only regularly reach one, A. (I’m using initials because Gazans are concerned about being targeted for retaliation if they criticize Israel).
We don’t discuss A.’s writing anymore. Instead, he sends me messages about how many hours he stands in line for bread each day without getting any (the record, so far, is 8). He sleeps with 50 other people on the floor of a hall with no working bathrooms, no electricity, and minimal food—as of a few days ago, his family was eating chocolate and chips as meals because it was all they could find on the emptying store shelves. But none of this is as pressing as the daily search for water.
A.’s family evacuated from their home in Gaza City to the southern city of Khan Yunis, per the IDF’s instructions, along with hundreds of thousands of other refugees. There’s no running water in most of the city, because Israel shut off the pipes leading into Gaza and won’t allow any fuel in to power its desalination plants.
At first, A. walked the streets looking to buy small bottles of water from any store that had them. Sometimes he’d find a few to split among his immediate family members. Eventually, though, the stores had none left, and his family started drinking unclean water from whatever source they could find. They haven’t seen any of the aid coming in on the few trucks allowed into Gaza, a fraction of what’s needed to keep the population of over 2 million people, half of whom are children, alive. In fact, A. hasn’t met anyone receiving the aid.
M., another WANN writer, messaged her mentor that “people are drinking from municipality water (which is for washing/cleaning and not for drinking) due to the severe lack of water. Some people use a filter to purify either that water or water from the sea! Some people have wells beneath their homes but they don’t have electricity to pump it. Some Mosques donated water for people. They have to be in a loooong queue to fill a bottle of water. Some people are lucky and the rest are not.”
“Obtaining water has become like prospecting for gold,” explains H., another writer, “and whoever finds drinkable water is considered wealthy. We have three yellow bottles that we carry long distances—about 7 km each way—to find water from a mosque, hospital, or water charity that runs on solar energy, which are being bombed these days. We go and wait for our turn, which takes almost two hours, to fill the containers under terrifying bombardment, and sometimes we do not find water at all due to the large number of people. I haven’t washed for a long time.” H. walks to fill his bottles even though his family has a vehicle, because they ran out of fuel.
Several days ago, I was awakened in the middle of the night by A. messaging me—here in the United States— to ask me to help him find water, as his family’s access to even the unclean municipal water had run out. He has a history of kidney stones and was terrified of his increasing dehydration.
I went into overdrive, contacting everyone I know with family in Gaza, asking if they knew of a water source in Khan Yunis. Instead, I got requests back asking for any information I might have on places to find water in Rafah, Deir Al-Balah, and Maghazi—because everyone’s family is desperate for it.
I reached out to the Middle East Children’s Alliance (MECA), an organization based in California that provides aid on the ground in Palestine. They had a small purification site in Khan Younis, but the IDF cut communications and by the time I was able to reach A. two days later, MECA’s purification system already had stopped working. A. told me that he’d found a small amount of foul-tasting municipal water. All of the small children in the family were experiencing fevers and other symptoms that a local pharmacist identified as a waterborne illness.
In Rafah and Maghazi, MECA’s units are in UNWRA schools sheltering thousands of people, I learned, and the water is being rationed to keep those people alive. There is nothing extra. In Deir Al-Balah, MECA’s unit is out of chemicals and, due to the siege, there’s no way to replenish them.
The situation changes daily. On Tuesday, A. reported that they’d found water they were told had been purified, but it was so chlorinated that it was hard to swallow and was hurting their stomachs. They drank it anyway, because they had to. Today I learned from MECA that water was turned back on in some parts of Khan Yunis, but in very limited quantities. I haven’t been able to reach A. to learn if he has access, or if he and his family are still surviving.
Dehydration isn’t the only problem. With the washing water being used for drinking, some people are using seawater to wash dishes or clothing. But because the wastewater treatment plants have no fuel, raw sewage is being pumped into that very seawater. Alice Rothchild, a physician on the board of the Gaza Mental Health Foundation, notes “hospitals do not have clean water for sanitizing wounds, surgical instruments, and facilities. In addition, bed-wetting among children, a sign of extreme trauma, has skyrocketed due to the constant bombing, drones, and death. But there is often no way to wash their sheets and clothes, and children are forced to sleep on urine-soaked mattresses.”
Yet it’s the lack of drinking water throughout most of Gaza that puts people at risk of imminent death. I googled how long a person can live without water. According to Medical News Today, “Dehydration happens quickly, causing extreme thirst, fatigue, and ultimately, organ failure and death. A person may go from feeling thirsty and slightly sluggish on the first day with no water to having organ failure by the third.”
I’m not sure what definition of “humanitarian crisis” the Israeli ambassador is using. Perhaps the real issue is that he does not consider Palestinians human.
Stop justifying genocide.
The murder of civilians by intentionally withholding food and water, and blockading all entrances to the area is explicitly a war crime.
You're on the wrong side of 'Never Again.'
Testimonies coming out now paintt the attack in a different light:
Residents of the kibbutz said that Hamas fighters told them not to be afraid as they were there to fight the IDF, and they state they were not harmed by Hamas.
In fact, they state that the Israeli military fired so much and so indiscriminately that it is very likely the high number of casualties were down to them.
Footage emerging shows Apache helicopters absolutely obliterating everything at the festival and the photos of the damaged vehicles could not have been caused by the weaponry that the Hamad fighters were armed with.
More than half of the original figure of 1600 killed were IDF, with that total being revised down to 1200 with only 1 child under 5.
You've been fed bullshit by a military that has a long track record for lying though it's teeth and bought into them hook line & sinker
https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20231030-report-7-october-testimonies-strikes-major-blow-to-israeli-narrative/
That is a great justification for murdering 5000+ children that had nothing to do with it you sick fuck.
When listed out in order of age on a standard piece of paper, you have to go six pages to get above the age of zero. And that was a week ago when the bombing and water scarcity has increased. I'm sure they had everything to do with the murder the festival goers.
I can't believe you're trying to justify baby murder.
You're literally justifying the murder of an order of magnitude more of children.
If that doesn't get you to think "Maybe we're the baddies", what would?
What about getting your head out of your ass you barbaric genocide sympathizer.
Wrong of Hamas to do. Doesn't justify cutting off food, water, electricity, and fuel to the strip nor bombing and killing over 11k civilians.
Get that "eye for an eye" shit out of here. The Israeli government has taken an eye, arm, leg, and more at this point.
An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
I'm calling them out for criticizing Israel for killing civilians, but failing to criticize Hamas for doing the exact same thing.
Calling who out? The Gazans that didn't dig up the pipes, didn't make the rockets, and didn't launch them towards Israel? Who is currently being bombed left and right, running out of supplies, and dying by the truckload? You sure showed them.
The people criticizing IDF for killing civilians while being unable to voice a single criticizm towards Hamas when they're doing the exact same thing.
The IDF has killed more than 10x the number of civilians and has caused suffering to way more. And that’s crediting Hamas with 1200 deaths, half of which were probably also the IDF based on recent reports. Sure people can criticize Hamas, but they’ve done considerably less damage in this conflict.
But is that because they're being much more considerate and careful around civilians than the IDF or is it simply just lack of resources? Imagine if the roles were reversed.
It doesn’t matter. I choose to criticize based on reality rather than hypothetical. If reality were different, then the criticisms would of course be different. In reality Israel has caused immense pain and suffering, choosing to carpet bomb civilian neighborhoods and prevent civilians from accessing food, medicine, and water. These are war crimes, and hugely disproportionate to the few hundreds of people killed by Hamas on October 7th.
None of what I'm saying disputes that. I hope Israel will be held accountable for all the crimes they've commited. I don't agree with how, but I agree with why they're doing it. What do you imagine they're even supposed to do? On top of the IDF's disregard, they're commonly used as human shields aswell.
Human shields is a weak argument, especially in a dense urban area. Of course there are going to be civilians around, they have no where else to go. It’s just a cheap excuse.
I also don’t actually agree with the why part of Israel’s actions here. They claim they want to get rid of Hamas and eventually promote peace, but their actions consistently have been against peace for decades, and the amount of genocidal rhetoric has only increased. If Israel wanted to promote peace, they’d be actively trying to improve overall prosperity and integrate the Palestinians into Israeli civil society. Grant first-class citizenship, voting rights, promote economic opportunities and celebrate their culture alongside Israeli culture. But they’re not doing any of that because that isn’t their goal, it’s to eradicate the Palestinians so the land can be re settled by Jewish Israelis. They need low level hostility from groups like Hamas to continue, because they need an excuse to continue their war, and so their war tactics are chosen to maximize causalities and radicalization of Palestinians while avoiding international intervention.
Dude you responded to the post itself. So it sounds like you're calling out the Palestinian civilians, especially when you said they should have thought about it before digging up pipes. It sounds like you're saying they deserve it for something Hamas did.
I was replying to Count042@lemmy.ml
I'm not disputing what they're saying. I just get the feeling, that people tend to be quite one-sided when it comes to this issue. I'm not actually even quite sure why I replied to this user in particular, as the message itself I mostly agree with.
No, you're calling out people criticizing attempted genocide. You try and change it to 'killing civilians' in a pathetically transparent attempt to accuse them of antisemitism for criticizing Israel, but not Hamas of killing civilians, while ignoring the genocide.
It is transparent. Everyone can see what you are doing. You are not clever.
Here are the problems with that:
It requires that you justify the murder of 5000+ children.
It supposes that Hamas and Israel are equal actors in equal situations. It requires ignoring the fact that one is the guerilla militant arm, and the other is a FUCKING NUCLEAR POWER WITH COMPLETE CONTROL OF THE BORDERS OF THE OTHER AND CONSTANTLY RESTRICTS THEIR ACCESS TO FOOD AND WATER. i.e. genocide when it is restricted completely, as it has been for the last month.
You're a disgusting fuck of a human being justifying genocide and the murder of children.
EDIT: You also didn't criticize Israel until it was pointed out that you were a child-murder justifying fuck. I.e. you did it after the fact to try and pretend that you aren't a child-murder justifying fuck.
Yet here you are still arguing.
I won't engage with your pathetic attempts to claim that people against genocide are antisemitic.
I sure will point it out to others when you do it.
Also, "Never Again" had no caveats you fucking monster.
Genocide is NEVER the answer. No matter the provocation.
I condemn Israel for the civilians they're killing in Gaza. I do not approve and I hope they will face the consequences for it.
Do you condemn Hamas for murdering the 250 innocent people at the peace rave? Are you able to critizice both sides or do you just turn a blind eye to the other?
Do you condemn Israel for lying & firing so indiscriminately at the festival crowds that they are very likely responsible for the vast majority of casualties?
https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20231030-report-7-october-testimonies-strikes-major-blow-to-israeli-narrative/
There's a ton I condemn Israel for. If this is true then I'll just add it to the list. Believe it or not, I condemn the murder of civilians period. It doesn't matter whose doing it. Plenty of religious extremism and disregard for others going on on both sides. That's why I'm not rooting for one or the another.
Hamas Terrorist Calls His Parents With Israeli Victim’s Phone to Brag About Slaughter: ‘Your Son Killed Jews!’
I don't answer to people that try and justify child murder.
I also didn't see you do that before your comment asking about the festival goer. So you're a liar, too. But, that is the least of your failures of morality.
I won't argue with you, in the same way that I won't engage in an argument about racism with a piece of shit that uses the N-word, you child-murder justifying fuck.