I don't think it's that easy. The academics of the left still leave plenty of room for subterfuge, even studied scholars don't always agree and even bicker at times. More over the academics aren't what draws people to leftism, direct action and engaging the communities we want to engage is what wins people over, academic first orgs end up looking like insular book clubs with slow and little growth in my experience and from the opinion of others I've read in books about organizing.

I think it serves the left better to meet the acute needs of their local communities, which to me serves as the center of organization. Very hard to argue against initiatives like the BPPs Breakfast Program. Which by the way was exactly what put them on the Feds radar, because my guess is the feds have accepted what I describe here as true, or at least best revolutionary practice. I also find organizing around the needs of the community to be very agreeable, I've been in orgs where they itemize our goals and use approval voting to rank them, and mutual aid items are more than usually very agreed upon.

I'd love a honest academic space, but even then our movement is a communal one, and if you're able to help in a 'boots on the ground' capacity but you only engage in academics instead, you likely won't really make to much material impact. Hell I'd love to be wrong about it being near impossible to have an honest leftist space too, and I don't want to give the feds more credit than they deserve for even the ills of the movement, we learn nothing that way, but it's really hard to cut through the noise when they specialize in noise. I'd wager some of these noisemakers have even read more anticapitalist books than some of the people who actually are anticapitalists.

I do think you're onto something though, the average understanding of the academics of leftism (why we do the things we do), is less understood among leftists than ever before. My guess is the increase in the number of leftists and how acceptable the beliefs are seen as being these days helps foster leftism among people who don't exactly read their heads off about theory.