Just want to take a moment to point out that two of the three you seem to like because they remind you of the past.

I fully support your take on trying to find new stuff, I personally have found that many good songs that I love take a few listens for me to actually like them, some do not catch on tho.

Given that, may I suggest you add new songs you want to try in your rotation? When they come up just take some effort to listen through and take them in, think of what you like and what you don't, see if it changes.

Don't torture yourself tho