15
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 06 Sep 2024
15 points (85.7% liked)
Books
10265 readers
16 users here now
Book reader community.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
You’re asking what our thoughts are on the high fantasy works that defined high fantasy? You’ll need to be a little more specific 😂
My thought on Andy Serkins’ reading is that it is the best audiobook ever made in the history of audiobooks. Regardless of whether one even likes the books, it’s still arguably the best reading of a work.
Agreed with the last part, though I know some that didn't like it.
And yes, giving your thoughts on The Silmarillion or even The Lord of the Rings entirely is fine!
I’ve read all of those (yes, even The Silmarillion). They’re the only high fantasy works I’ve read, so I’m not in a position to compare it to others in the genre. I’m not interested in the genre in general, but AFAIK these are unique in terms of the depth and breadth of world building that he sets them in. ~20,000 years of astoundingly detailed history of an area the size of Europe, a sumptuous attention to languages, and a whole cosmology laid out from the beginning of time.
The Silmarillion is for masochists only. I only read it because I was trapped somewhere once with no internet and nothing to do for a long time. A lot of it reads like the Old Testament (I think: hell if I’m ever going to pore through the Bible).
The work is racist and reactionary; divine rights of kings and such. From an ML-perspective it’s hot garbage. But whatever, it’s not like it’ll give you liberal cooties.
From what I hear, the ~~Netflix~~ Amazon show would be considered non-canon, if you care about such things. It compresses thousands of years into a human lifetime. I only watched the first three-or-so episodes and lost interest. I’m not very interested in a series that makes minced meat of the world that’s already built in my head from the original material, especially when high fantasy isn’t even my bag.
Netflix show?
There's an Amazon show. What Netflix show, if any?
Right… I meant Amazon.
Oh yeah gotcha
I read The Bible, Old and New Testament, and the Old Testament at least is much more dry.
Also, yeah, The Lord of the Rings series is dated, of course.