545
Rule of owning
(lemmy.ml)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 10 Oct 2024
545 points (98.1% liked)
196
16744 readers
3105 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
This is also the case for physical copies, and has been since software was first sold
According to media lawyers, maybe. But when I have a CD of music, or a game cartridge, I can sell it to someone else. For money. Because it's my copy I'm selling. So, what the fuck are you talking about except ceding the point to corporate lawyers for no good reason?
You own the license and can sell the license (generally), not the actual game. To use an analogy, if you buy and own a car, you could take it apart or replace any part you like, put the engine into another car, etc. You can't do the equivalent with a typical game and other propertary software, at least not legally, because you don't own it, you just own the right to use it.
Might not make a noticable difference to most people because most people don't do much with games/software apart from using it, but there still is a difference.
That's technically piracy. You should be careful as some have been sued for selling 2nd hand goods.
Just because it makes sense and is intuitive doesn't make it correct legally speaking
No it's not. It's well established law that we are allowed to resell our physical media. You're just wrong. Like I said, if it were up to corporate media lawyers, you would be correct, which is why it's frustrating to see people like OP & yourself falling into line when no one's even asking you to. Stop that.
I am not falling in line, I am asking you to be aware so you don't get sued for doing a reasonable thing. Maybe games are safe but I heard of other goods causing lawsuits.
Take my word with a grain of salt, but as far as I understand with my limited knowledge, you do not own the content stored on the disc; however, you do own the physical medium itself. That is how game stores are allowed to sell you second hand games. They aren't selling you the disc contents, they are selling you the disc. Regardless, readers, do your own research and don't take the word of random people on Lemmy including myself.
Yeah, if a game needs online activation it doesn't matter which medium you buy...
That's a lie told by every new industry since the printing press. Books tried writing "by anonymously exchanging money for this mass-produced object, you've secretly entered into a contract that limits your" blah blah blah. Courts threw that shit out, one hundred years ago. Same thing happened for videos and music.
Only software emerged recently enough, and under enough corruption, to keep pretending that opening shrink-wrap was magically the same as ink-on-paper agreement to some negotiated tradeoff.
Moving to digital distribution changed nothing. These assholes would be the first to insist as much. They would agree, you own Factorio on Steam in exactly the same way you own SimCity on SNES. But anyone who points to the cartridge in your hands and insists "you don't own that" is being a fucking idiot.