Also not in the religion, they're specifically instructed that they're not to make judgements or enact any punishments on the behalf of god, which this is.

I think even that is reaching. Most of them don't want to punish women for extramarital sex, they just think God's will is that those women deserve what they get. Of course they still defy God's will by wearing glasses if God gave them bad eyes, but that's just more shoddy reasoning.