I just wrapped up my first NG+ run of Elden Ring, which also included my first playthrough of Shadow of the Erdtree. I enjoy the base game quite a bit, and while I think it loses a bit of steam during the last third or so of the game (in regards to the environments; the bosses are cool), I intend to do a second NG+ playthrough to try to get the Lord of Frenzied Flame ending as well as the legendary achievements. I'm not an achievement hunter or anything, but 100%ing Elden Ring sounds like a fun goal to have. It's a toss up if I'll revisit Shadow of the Erdtree, because I'm pretty neutral on it.
In the meantime, I've returned to my first save file of Dark Souls that I put down at Sen's Fortress a year or so ago. I just wasn't having it, but this time everything clicked, the snake dudes caused me no trouble, and I made it to Anor Londo. But now I'm dealing with the AL archers and they are a real pain. I wouldn't be surprised if I put it down again and revisit it at the end of 2026.