Since I grew up abroad I don't feel like enough of a german and looking around me I'm damn glad
you can be a multitude. you can feel 100% norwegian, 100% american and 100% german if it feels right to you. don't ever think that you're not "enough of a nationality". nations are modern inventions- they shift, they come and go. how and what we identity with is complex and difficult- and that's normal. try to go with your gut feeling - it's usually right, even if your head won't always understand it at first. tldr; don't let others tell you you're not enough, when in truth you're probably more than them.
thank you :)
Well I don't look like the overwhelming majority of people in my day to day life, and share near zero experience and cultural exposure with the people who do look like me.
So yes.
I was born in the southern hemisphere and have lived in different countries in Europe for many many years. I speak 4 languages and remember a bit of what I learned of native (precolonial culture) from the country I was born in. Although I was born in a different country, my family is Italian on one side and Palestinian on the other. I feel from nowhere.
My take, people crave identity through whatever can give them a sense of legitimacy and belonging. Vikings are just 300 years of romanticised history, but there is certainly rich culture in it. If you find beauty in the themes and traditions of germanic scandinavia or the sápmi then great! I feel attached for no reason to some cultures and traditions because they "make sense" to me in my view of the world and my values. We do not need certificates for that.
I'm such a mix that really can't claim a single European heritage. My family has mixed old traditions together and tossed out others for others which conformed more to where my family was.
I don't see the need to be X enough for something.
I grew up in Australia. My cultural heritage (3 to 4 generations back) is mostly Irish and English. It's safe to say I don't particularly relate to either of them because until I did my family tree, I couldn't have told you which sides of my family come from which part of the UK.
And that leaves Australia. But I don't particularly feel drawn to an Australian identity either, because mainstream Australian culture mostly feels like a generic "Western" culture, with the edges rubbed off. I'm also well aware that the country as it stands today was founded on invasion and genocide, and to this day, is unable to let go of the racism that lead to those events.
So yeah, I'm Australian, but I don't feel emotionally attached to that identity.
That makes sense :)
I am Norwegian and I have, for as long as I remember, considered Norwegian culture to be a bit hollow, boring and hypocritical. What about Norwegian culture makes you want to connect with it?
Have you lived abroad for some time? Because I felt similar towards my home culture, still sort of do, but learned to appreciate it more after having lived in different cultures for some years.
I have lived abroad twice in my life. There are many things I appreciate about Norway, such as the stable economy and clean air and water. The culture I still feel somewhere between neutral or negative about.
That aligns perfectly with American culture.
Fair enough. I don't consider myself a true Norwegian, just an American with Norwegian culture influence. Well, truth be told, I don't remember much but I was raised with the language on videos and culture videos. We always considered Christmas to be "jul", well my Dad did.
So basically just bits of the language, sadly :,)
I don’t have a quick answer to your question but as someone who was born in America with a family that celebrates our Scotch-Irish heritage, I have a view/opinion on this topic that might be of some use to you.
The way I see it, people have two types of heritage, ethnic heritage and cultural heritage.
In my long winded explanation, Norwegian is your ethnic heritage, ethnic heritage has to do with your family and where they come from. The best way I can describe it is, a blend of where your family originated from plus the traditions that they still hold on to. Ethnic heritage is more rigid and unchanging.
Cultural heritage is more flexible, it’s influenced by where you grew up and where you currently live. It’s influenced by your friends and the types of media or leisure activities that you all enjoy.
Caveat: This is just an opinion that I’ve been toying around with, it’s not a fully fleshed out idea that I have any empirical evidence to back any of this up. I am open to constructive criticism that will help hone this mess of ideas into something more poignant.
No, because it doesn't really matter when you think about it. I am half Welsh half Australian and I have no real interest in the Welsh half as I was born and raised in Australia.
Makes sense, thank you :)
Asklemmy
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- !lemmy411@lemmy.ca: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de~