A senior officer of China’s Public Security Bureau who spent more than three decades supervising interrogations and detentions in Hebei Province has been barred from Canadian permanent residency — along with his wife and child — after a federal immigration officer found reasonable grounds to believe he was complicit in the systematic torture of criminal suspects.
Justice Shirzad Ahmed upheld that finding on judicial review, in a ruling that carries indirect ramifications for Prime Minister Mark Carney’s controversial decision to deepen cooperation with Chinese police.
...
Carney’s government signed the memorandum of understanding with the Ministry of Public Security — the same national apparatus that oversees the provincial bureaus whose conduct the court condemned — without releasing the agreement’s text or explaining what protections exist for diaspora communities. As The Bureau has reported, critics from Hong Kong diaspora organizations have raised “deep fear and anxiety” over the deal.
The Chinese officer, referred to in the ruling only as the spouse of applicant Li Li, built a 30-year career inside the Shijiazhuang Municipal Public Security Bureau in Hebei Province, rising from criminal brigade investigator to vice director of one of its branches in 2013.
...
The ruling appears to add weight to systemic concerns ... including classified Canadian Security Intelligence Service warnings that Ministry of Public Security officers have run covert and unauthorized operations on Canadian soil, including surveillance of diaspora members, coercion of family members in China, and payments to Chinese-language journalists in Canada to locate and track targets.
Those warnings are consistent with a body of international documentation stretching back decades.
A landmark 2015 Human Rights Watch report found that physical and psychological abuse during Public Security Bureau interrogations was pervasive — so much so that even Chinese officials had characterized torture in custody as "common," "serious," and "nationwide."
...
Former detainees described being hung by the wrists, beaten with batons, and subjected to prolonged sleep deprivation; some were held for days in tiger chairs designed to immobilize suspects, or bound in handcuffs and leg irons. One prisoner awaiting review of a death sentence had been handcuffed and shackled continuously for eight years. An analysis of 432 court verdicts found that judges rarely investigated torture allegations in any meaningful way.
...
Drawing on reports from international non-governmental organizations, academic literature, and contemporaneous statements from the Chinese government itself, the officer concluded that torture during interrogations and detentions was systematic and policy-driven within the Public Security Bureau — not merely in pockets of the country, but nationwide, and specifically documented in Hebei Province.
...