Really it depends on how your employer handles expenses for travel, and how lax they are about verifying receipts.
Several places where I've worked have had things in place that would stop this kind of thing from occurring (whether that was the intended purpose behind those things or not)
But if they only require you submit the purchase receipt, then you might be able to do what you suggest. But if there's any info on the receipt that could lead them back to the canceled ticket (confirmation number, etc) then it could backfire on you if they check it. They could probably even use the credit card transaction number to the same end. But I'd expect that to be more involved and less likely unless you did something to make them suspicious.
Possible? Maybe. Risky? Also maybe.