139

Ukrainian-born model winning Miss Japan re-ignites identity debate (www.bbc.com)

submitted 10 months ago by MicroWave@lemmy.world to c/world@lemmy.world

58 comments fedilink hide all child comments

"There have been racial barriers, and it has been challenging to be accepted as Japanese."

That's what a tearful Carolina Shiino said in impeccable Japanese after she was crowned Miss Japan on Monday.

The 26-year-old model, who was born in Ukraine, moved to Japan at the age of five and was raised in Nagoya.

She is the first naturalised Japanese citizen to win the pageant, but her victory has re-ignited a debate on what it means to be Japanese.

While some recognised her victory as a "sign of the times", others have said she does not look like what a "Miss Japan" should.

top 50 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[-] tunetardis@lemmy.ca 96 points 10 months ago

She grew up in Japan. All her friends are Japanese. Her life experience is of Japanese society and culture. She's been through it all. What is she if not Japanese? Get over it.

I am part Japanese myself and the language is literally my mother tongue, but when I go to Japan to visit family, I always feel alienated because I don't look the part. Don't get me wrong. People are very polite to foreigners, but you will always be a foreigner. Even when I spent a year at a Japanese elementary school, I felt this persistent sense of not belonging.

But maybe things are starting to change? I admittedly have not been back in a couple of decades. I hope so.

[-] prettybunnys@sh.itjust.works 28 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

My neighbor who was born in Pakistan and moved to the USA in 3rd grade, and now has a kid going to school with mine, is more American than I’ll ever be tbh.

his moms brisket samosas are dope as fuck and ought to be enshrined in a immigrant fusion cookbook

Japan has had a long history of being insular, putting it lightly, so this is big regardless of how you look at it

load more comments (42 replies)

[-] Jiggle_Physics@lemmy.world 70 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

If Japan doesn't want to go into a death spiral as it's population shrinks they will need to get used to the idea of immigrants being common, and being a Japanese citizen is what makes you Japanese.

[-] Gigan@lemmy.world 1 points 10 months ago

That's how it works in America, but not every country is so progressive.

[-] Witchfire@lemmy.world 60 points 10 months ago

Half our country still struggles with that

[-] deegeese@sopuli.xyz 23 points 10 months ago

You say you were born here, but where are you from?

[-] JoMiran@lemmy.ml 14 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

I am very mixed race, including 18% native american and 24% west African (slave). That's according to DNA analysis. According to my grandmother's genealogy efforts, the only member to immigrate to the US after 1776 was Irish and he married the "creole" (white+black+native+???) plantation owners daughter. Resistance was futile. He was assimilated.

So most of my bloodline has been here since the start, 18% before that, but because I am not white and my features' origins are hard to define, I get asked where I am from fairly often. I've been even told to go back to my country.

Racism and xenophobia are dumb.

[-] FaceDeer@kbin.social 5 points 10 months ago

The other option is "death spiral as its population shrinks", I suppose there's nothing stopping Japan from choosing that instead.

[-] stoly@lemmy.world 1 points 10 months ago

This is not progressive. It was meant specifically to end slavery.

[-] ArbitraryValue@sh.itjust.works 20 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

The issue isn't really where she was born - even if she had been born in Japan, she still wouldn't be ethnically Japanese. The general idea in the USA seems to be that living in America is what makes someone an American, and this is a way of defining national identity that works well in an era of large-scale immigration. However, it's not how people generally define their identity. For example, I was born in Ukraine and my ancestors all lived in Ukraine for centuries, but I don't think of myself as Ukrainian and they didn't think of themselves as Ukrainian; they identified themselves and were identified by their neighbors as members of a different ethnic group.

I'm not sure where I'm going with that - I empathize with how this woman must be hurt by the criticism her victory is receiving because I came to the USA when I was about as old as she was when she came to Japan and if I were rejected from the community of Americans then I wouldn't have another community to go to, but I also empathize with people who think that being Japanese is about more than just living in Japan and following Japanese customs because I was raised to believe that about my own identity.

[-] Candelestine@lemmy.world 13 points 10 months ago

were identified by their neighbors as members of a different ethnic group.

There's simply nothing good that comes from this, except a comforting sense of superiority from any majority group, that is not necessarily deserved.

We have Amish here in the US, that have lived cloistered lives for centuries now, keeping to their own culture. But when you meet one out-and-about, you don't necessarily immediately jump to "Amish", even though they are pretty recognizable. They're just accepted, as a normal part of American society in this area, that belongs. Their Amish identity is simply not very important, nothing important comes from focusing on it. Since they're common, you just get used to them.

[-] ArbitraryValue@sh.itjust.works 2 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

There’s simply nothing good that comes from this

Oh, it was certainly very bad for my ancestors, but the lesson there isn't "It's better to assimilate," but rather "Even if you do everything to assimilate, your neighbors won't accept you, so remember that you're different. At least that way, you'll be prepared."

Since [the Amish are] common, you just get used to them.

I wouldn't say that - IMO, since the Amish are very rare, they're seen as an amusing curiosity rather than as any sort of threat. If they really were common, there probably would have been more hostility.

[-] Candelestine@lemmy.world 8 points 10 months ago

It's regional. Your experiences wherever you live are not reflective of the experiences of people that live nearby to Amish communities, where they are not a rare or amusing curiosity. They're just the people down the highway a bit.

[-] scytale@lemm.ee 13 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

Yeah, unlike a melting pot such as the US, countries like Japan are relatively ethnically homogeneous, and no matter how fluent you are in the language or how long you’ve lived there, you’ll always be a gaijin (foreigner), especially if you look way different (i.e. western). Fortunately, I think as the newer generation slowly takes over, large-scale immigration nowadays is getting more accepted as the world becomes more interconnected.

[-] TranscendentalEmpire@lemm.ee 10 points 10 months ago

However, it's not how people generally define their identity. For example, I was born in Ukraine and my ancestors all lived in Ukraine for centuries, but I don't think of myself as Ukrainian and they didn't think of themselves as Ukrainian

I think this is kinda the point, that the way ethnicities define themselves are typically based on a misunderstanding of genetics and a bygone definition of race.

I for example am half Korean and half Czech, according to how both those ethnicities self identify I don't really qualify for either. To my Korean family I'm a tall white guy who looks kinda Korean, To my Czech family I'm just a very big Korean dude.

I personally think that ethnicity and culture should be shared, and that gate keeping culture based on antiquated ideologies like race just perpetuates our worse tribal instincts.

Of course that could be some implicit biases coming out to play. If I believed that ethnic purity was a beneficial quality, I'd be in trouble.

[-] Witchfire@lemmy.world 5 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

To add, diversity is beneficial in basically all aspects of nature. A natural land that isn't biodiverse is prone to disease and competition for resources. Purebred pets tend to be more prone to disease and complications than "mutts". "Ethnic purity" is such a self centered and stupid virtue for someone to have in this day and age.

Furthermore, a lot of cultural traditions like food and music are meant to be shared with others, and locking yourself out of that because of some ass backwards view is a disservice to oneself.

Racists confuse the hell out of me

[-] ReallyKinda@kbin.social 1 points 10 months ago

Culture is place-based. It’s about how the geography and food and local population and local religious practices shape you and it is constantly evolving because all of those things change over time. It is not genetic. As japan welcomes more immigrants those immigrants will indeed shift the culture in certain ways because there is a new group of people. Pageants are about cultural celebration, and Japan is celebrating their culture with this beautiful woman who calls it home.

[-] jordanlund@lemmy.world 17 points 10 months ago

Locking the thread... This is one of those stories that as soon as I saw it, my gut reaction was "Oh, no good will come from this."

Lots of reports, overt racism, covert racism, comments removed, users banned...

Saving you from yourselves. This is why we can't have nice things.

[-] autotldr@lemmings.world 3 points 10 months ago

This is the best summary I could come up with:

That's what a tearful Carolina Shiino said in impeccable Japanese after she was crowned Miss Japan on Monday.

The 26-year-old model, who was born in Ukraine, moved to Japan at the age of five and was raised in Nagoya.

Her win comes nearly 10 years after Ariana Miyamoto became the first bi-racial woman to be crowned Miss Japan in 2015.

Back then, with a Japanese mother and African American father, Ms Miyamoto's victory raised questions about whether a person of mixed race should be eligible to win the competition.

Now, the fact Ms Shiino has no Japanese parentage has upset some on social media.

Ai Wada, the organiser of the Miss Japan Grand Prix pageant told the BBC that judges had chosen Ms Shiino as the winner with "full confidence".

The original article contains 421 words, the summary contains 130 words. Saved 69%. I'm a bot and I'm open source!

[-] badbytes@lemmy.world 2 points 10 months ago

Buttttt, she no looky japaneseee.

Funny how ethic actors face the same kinds of issues.

load more comments

this post was submitted on 24 Jan 2024

139 points (96.0% liked)

World News

39112 readers

755 users here now

A community for discussing events around the World

Rules:

Rule 1: posts have the following requirements:
- Post news articles only
- Video links are NOT articles and will be removed.
- Title must match the article headline
- Not United States Internal News
- Recent (Past 30 Days)
- Screenshots/links to other social media sites (Twitter/X/Facebook/Youtube/reddit, etc.) are explicitly forbidden, as are link shorteners.
Rule 2: Do not copy the entire article into your post. The key points in 1-2 paragraphs is allowed (even encouraged!), but large segments of articles posted in the body will result in the post being removed. If you have to stop and think "Is this fair use?", it probably isn't. Archive links, especially the ones created on link submission, are absolutely allowed but those that avoid paywalls are not.
Rule 3: Opinions articles, or Articles based on misinformation/propaganda may be removed. Sources that have a Low or Very Low factual reporting rating or MBFC Credibility Rating may be removed.
Rule 4: Posts or comments that are homophobic, transphobic, racist, sexist, anti-religious, or ableist will be removed. “Ironic” prejudice is just prejudiced.
Posts and comments must abide by the lemmy.world terms of service UPDATED AS OF 10/19
Rule 5: Keep it civil. It's OK to say the subject of an article is behaving like a (pejorative, pejorative). It's NOT OK to say another USER is (pejorative). Strong language is fine, just not directed at other members. Engage in good-faith and with respect! This includes accusing another user of being a bot or paid actor. Trolling is uncivil and is grounds for removal and/or a community ban.

Similarly, if you see posts along these lines, do not engage. Report them, block them, and live a happier life than they do. We see too many slapfights that boil down to "Mom! He's bugging me!" and "I'm not touching you!" Going forward, slapfights will result in removed comments and temp bans to cool off.

Rule 6: Memes, spam, other low effort posting, reposts, misinformation, advocating violence, off-topic, trolling, offensive, regarding the moderators or meta in content may be removed at any time.
Rule 7: We didn't USED to need a rule about how many posts one could make in a day, then someone posted NINETEEN articles in a single day. Not comments, FULL ARTICLES. If you're posting more than say, 10 or so, consider going outside and touching grass. We reserve the right to limit over-posting so a single user does not dominate the front page.

We ask that the users report any comment or post that violate the rules, to use critical thinking when reading, posting or commenting. Users that post off-topic spam, advocate violence, have multiple comments or posts removed, weaponize reports or violate the code of conduct will be banned.

All posts and comments will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. This means that some content that violates the rules may be allowed, while other content that does not violate the rules may be removed. The moderators retain the right to remove any content and ban users.