I'm not putting my totp with my password, same as I'm not putting my password with my email (proton)
Exactly, from a security perspective, it's a bad idea to put 2 factor tokens together with your passwords. You effectively eliminate the security benefit that 2 factor provides if you do because if people get into your password manager, they have everything they need to access your accounts. The only people it "helps" having it all in one app are people who don't understand the purpose of 2 factor and just see it as an inconvenience when services force it on them. Even though I use BitWarden for passwords, I don't think that I'll be changing from Aegis to BitWarden's stand-alone authenticator because Aegis is doing its job nicely.
That's also part of why I'm against the new passkeys. I think passkeys could replace either passwords or tokens, but not both.
And seemingly reading beyond the headline is also not your thing.
This is a separate app unconnected to your bitwarden account...
Good. They make great stuff.
Nice. But as a BitWarden user, it's useless to me. I've never put all my eggs in one account basket.
Passwords on one service, MFA on another, email on yet another, etc.
Any reason to switch from Aegis?
Not yet.
No icons, no ability to save notes, a URL or back it up in an encrypted json.
I will definitely keep an eye on it though.
Thats what i want to know, i use Authy, and want to know if its worth switching for.
I personally have no use for this since I use Aegis and sync it with my synology drive
I assume its still absolutely impossible to migrate from one authenticator app to another without having to set it all up again?
You can use Authenticator Pro (android, opensesource) and Proton Pass, both let you copy the TOTP generation code to paste into another without problem. Both generate exact code
In fact that's how I am using them right now, with Authenticator Pro is my on-device, offline, encrypted backup offline backup TOTP for Pass.
I guess it is not as straight forward as export import as you hope, but it's not as bad as other options used to be.
As long as you can access the keys, you can swap authenticator apps.
I tried a few until I landed in Aegis, and I have two on my desktop that I'm trying out as well. Just get something that allows exporting the keys and there will be a path to switching apps.
Why not just use Strongbox? All of that’s built in and don’t have to store your vault on their cloud.
Technology
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed