Can assignment be used with null conditional operators? (programming.dev)

submitted 1 year ago by slardiaardvark@programming.dev to c/csharp@programming.dev

4 comments fedilink hide all child comments

With regards to null conditional operators, calling properties and methods will work fine, e.g.:

HttpContext.Current?.Response.Clear();

But I'm wondering if assignment is possible? I get this error when trying to do this:

HttpContext.Current?.Response.ContentType = "text/json";

The docs say:

The null-conditional operators are short-circuiting. That is, if one operation in a chain of conditional member or element access operations returns null, the rest of the chain doesn't execute.

So wondering if it's possible and I'm doing it wrong, or am I taking "does not execute" too literally? :)

top 4 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[-] atheken@programming.dev 1 points 1 year ago

When there is ambiguity in the behavior of something like this, it’s usually easier to just construct a unit test and see what happens.

Make a class with some deeply nested members and then do an assignment.

See what happens.

[-] kogasa@programming.dev 0 points 1 year ago

What is the precise expected behavior here? If HttpContext.Current?.Response.ContentType is not null, then assign it to "text/json", otherwise explode? I would intuitively evaluate the latter case as trying to assign null = "text/json" which doesn't make sense to me.

[-] slardiaardvark@programming.dev 0 points 1 year ago

What is the precise expected behavior here?

Oh just because the docs said "The null-conditional operators are short-circuiting" and "the rest of the chain doesn’t execute" I wondered, if the object is null, it would just skip executing the assignment completely. Didn't have high hopes, but thought I'd ask just in case, as it would be kinda handy as well. Probably pretty rarely though.

[-] Lmaydev@programming.dev 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

What it does essentially is a null check and jump after each member.

So what you would end up with is null = ... As the result of the expression (chain) is what is being assigned to. The assignment is an expression its self that takes two expressions. One to be assigned to and the value to assign.

Which obviously is always going to be an error.