Prime Minister Mark Carney would not say when asked whether China’s treatment of the Uyghurs amounted to genocide – as the House of Commons declared several years ago – but acknowledged the Asian country was “rightly called out” for its conduct toward this minority in the past.
Speaking to reporters Tuesday at an unrelated news conference in Quebec, Mr. Carney was asked whether he agreed with the [Canada's] 2021 House of Commons motion on genocide.
He declined to say but noted “there are fundamental issues in terms of China’s treatment of the Uyghurs in the past, and they’ve been rightly called out.”
Mr. Carney is still navigating the fallout from comments from new Liberal MP Michael Ma who last week cast doubt on reports of forced labour in China. Mr. Ma, who defected from the opposition Conservatives in December, has since apologized for his statements.
...
Mr. Ma sparked a backlash last Thursday after he challenged the existence of forced labour in China during a meeting of the Commons industry committee, which is examining Mr. Carney’s deal to allow 49,000 Chinese-made electric vehicles into Canada at a low tariff rate.
...
Last week, Margaret McCuaig-Johnston, a senior fellow at the Graduate School of Public and International Affairs at the University of Ottawa, had told the Commons industry committee Thursday that electric vehicles (EV) are being built with Chinese aluminum products made by slave labourers in Xinjiang. A 2024 Human Rights Watch report also said major automakers including Tesla, BYD, GM, Toyota and Volkswagen are drawing aluminum from supply chains linked to Uyghur forced labour in Xinjiang.
...
Uyghurs and other Turkic minorities in Xinjiang, a region some call East Turkestan, have faced years of repression, forced internment and coerced labour under Beijing, according to rights groups. A 2022 report from the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights said China has committed “serious human rights violations” there that may amount to “crimes against humanity.”
Look, as much as I’m sure you aren’t wrong about it being a conservative mouthpiece Carney is just a really shitty person who has no idea what he’s doing actually running a country.
Interestingly, the Liberals are barely left of the Conservatives but if people start seeing them as functionally the same as Conservatives then we become a proper multi-party country again, and if we’re lucky we even start seeing the conservative vote being split while the NDP enjoy some space. This country is only going to get worse, in the way it’s been getting worse in front of out eyes for a long time now, if we keep this up.
I'm a leftist so I generally hate Carney for a ton of reasons, but "has no idea what he's doing" is absolutely incorrect; he's been doing very well in response to the US and his actions have undoubtedly helped Canada. He's good for business and great for the economy; the country would be far weaker and in a much worse place if conservatives had won.
Far from ideal, and I'd much rather see the NDP gain ground... But from the realistic options Canadians had: I think they made the best choice possible and it's already paid dividends.
Read my other comment in here. Thinking Carney is doing good things for Canada requires a heavy amount of not paying attention to what he’s doing. He’s literally running the Liberals closer to Harper-era Conservatives than anything and we desperately need aggressive progress, not weak, middling responses.
If “Canada will unconditionally supprt the US in its attack on Iran” is what you call a strong response I mean fucking yikes, dude.
(From a CBC article)
Far from perfect, certainly not 'unconditional'...
It was the first thing he said. He sinced walked it back, but his gut reaction was “unconditional”.
French article
No nuance, no “limited aspect”, he just went directly to sucking Trump’s dick until someone stopped him. Carney’s an empty suit who doesn’t give a shit about you. It was obvious to me back when he looked like a kid wearing his dad’s hockey jersey meekly talking about “elbows up”. He doesn’t stand for anything but monied interests and he’s not even hiding it.
I completely agree with you there. And for those very reasons he's doing pretty good on the economy despite the circumstances. And his pushback against the Americans is far more than what the likes of Poilierve would do.
Doing pretty well in the eyes of Canadians too
https://www.ipsos.com/en-ca/carney-approval-climbs-after-one-year-outpacing-poilievre-support-momentum
Could someone else be better? Probably.
Would almost anyone else be worse? Definitely.
Is he "bad" for Canada? Absolutely not.
But the election is what it was, and Canada made the best possible realistic choice with the options it had. All things considered, it's going pretty damn well. I have boatloads of criticisms, but the fact that his leadership has been a net positive is almost undeniable.
If I sighed any louder I’d shake the paintings off the wall.
The Conservatives are not a valid point of reference. The fight needs to change to be between the progressives in the NDP and the conservatives in the Liberal party and constantly dodging that only serves to validate the Conservatives. You don’t fight the far-right by treating it like a serious ideology while dismissing the progressive options.
I’m also not surprised that he’s doing well in the eyes of Canadians, most of us are incredibly poorly informed. Hell, I’m telling you guys here all the terrible shit he’s done and you’re just walking right past it, but if I bring up the NDP ya’ll will find any reason to claim they couldn’t lead, even if I could shut it down quickly with simple google searches.
I said I'd much prefer the NDP gain ground but that didn't happen and an NDP prime minister just wasn't in the cards. Strategic voting is very much still a thing.
Even if it wasn't, the fight against the far right and fascism isn't won magically by getting the right person in power; if anything, that happens last...
My statement is simply that Carney is, by just about every metric, good for Canada, and things would be significantly worse if he hadn't won. That's all. No ideology, no morality, no favoritism; I don't even like the guy. It's just how it is.
Tell me what strategic voting actually is, and how strategic it is after all this time to continually weaken the NDP while validating the Liberal’s move further and further to the right.
You need to actually respond to all the things I said showing very clearly how he is not good for Canada, how he is actively hurting the country. You looked at a cake, a stab wound, and a bullet to the chest and said “well at least the stab wound is better than the bullet!”, that failed, and now you’re embarrassed. I don’t care, just do better next time.
I don't especially like Carney, but you lose all credibility with:
He is literally and figuratively one of the most qualified people on the planet for the job. He quickly laid out a coherent plan that is not only right for Canada and generally approved by Canadians, but a bold, and soberingly accurate assessment for our friends and allies around the world.
I award you no points, and may god have mercy on your soul.
I rarely downvote just for disagreeing, but this stinks of bad faith.
Carney cheered the US/Israel's attacks on Iran, which have since led to Iran placing a chokehold on the global economy. We are about to see massive and prolonged spikes in the price of fuel, energy, food, and a whole lot of consumer goods because of this. But the genius banker cheered. Don't forget that.
All while Carney doubles and triples down on fossil fuel expansion, further tying Canada's economy to the thing that the rest of the world is now 100% committed to getting away from, in order to avoid being subjected to these repeated economic shocks - not to mention the big crisis of climate change. Carney is a fool.
Partial truths. That's some serious tinting on your glasses.
He’s fucking useless. He’s firing tens of thousands of federal workers and recently just made a deal with Doug Ford to wave off $8.8bil worth of development fees for new homes which will not lead to lower house prices but will lead to taxpayers in more responsibly built places subsidizing low-density neighbourhoods even more than they already are. Weird that he could find a way to wave $8.8bil dollars but still needs to fire so many people in a time where the unemployment rate is already so fucking high.
Air Canada flight attendants exercise their rights? Don’t worry, Carney will be there to declare the strike illegal and try to force them back to work. He had more to say about the CEO not saying “sorry for your loss” in French than about Air Canada’s horrible payment practices.
He’s also giving massive breaks to O&G companies, many of which are based in the US, and some of those little bits of help are letting them tear up our environment without review.
When the US attacked Iran it took only a few hours for him to declare that Canada would “unconditionally support” the US.
STILL no electoral reform, too. The fact that the Liberals refuse to execute on that, because the non-partisan in committee found that they’d likely never win again, should disqualify them in the eyes of most any voter who actually wants a real democracy. It’s not hard to do, they simply won’t do it. Ten years and still nothing.
He’s fucking terrible, has no clue how to actually run a country, and I have no idea what you’re smoking that makes that look like good leadership but you might want to lay off before it fully cooks your brain.
It's wild that you're being accused of bad faith considering you're repeatedly pointing out actual things that Carney has done, whereas the people arguing with you are just saying these broad platitudes, stuff like "he's good for Canada by every metric"
Exactly. The only positives I ever hear about him is how he’s boring and is totally doing things the NDP could never(zero evidence or historical data provided to back that crap up) and/or how he isn’t PP which is like, any of the options weren’t PP besides the ghoul himself.
I’m so tired of this country sometimes. We have no fight in us, to the point where the best we can offer is a terrified center-right vote and I get more aggression for saying that’s dumb than the Liberals get for the past ten years of getting in the way of any true progress.