1
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 01 Jun 2024
1 points (50.9% liked)
cats
19320 readers
921 users here now
typical internet cats. videos, pics, memes welcome!
rule 1) be kind
other cat communities midwest.social cats
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Shorter lives? My first cat became 17 years old before she passed away. Of course cats can live outdoors, especially here in Scandiavia, the majority of cats cats live outdoors.
Okay, if not for your own cat's safety then do it for the good of the environment.
House cats are non-native species who are subsidized by humans feeding them. Thus they can kill purely for pleasure and often do. Every year, house cats kill billions of birds (and rodents) and it's an ecological nightmare that is putting massive pressure on wildlife.
Please, just don't do it. It's unnecessary. You can create a stimulating environment inside and if you cannot then you shouldn't get a cat.
You have to be a human to ruin biodiversity, it's a known fact.
Norwegian forest cats are meant to be outdoors throughout the year even. Forcing these cats to stay indoors is considered animal abuse here. I'm not going to do that. While they do hunt sometimes, they also help get rid of rats and other pesty things... So they're not all that bad..
Even the people we got these cats from refused to give them away to people who would keep them indoors only. It's much like people who get Huskies while only keeping them in as pets in cities. They're not meant for that. These cats are outdoor animals like many other, wether you like it or not.
Just because it's cultural doesn't mean it's not problematic. Ignore the issues if you want, it doesn't make them go away.
I believe it to be different for us, Norway is extremely rich on wildlife. These cats are meant to be outdoors, and have for a long time, and is likely to stay that way for generations. It's fraud upon keeping cats indoors here.
If they're meant to be outdoors then don't feed and shelter them. That's giving them an unfair competitive advantage against both their prey and other predators. Every rodent a house cat kills is a rodent that another predator doesn't get. It leads to overpopulation and the eradication of their natural prey. In nature, if a predator's prey is over-hunted without human intervention, then predators die off and the populations correct themselves (predators die off or move until the equilibrium is reached again). This cannot happen if you feed the animals when food becomes scarce and heal them (veterinarian) when they are injured. You are interceding in natural processes.
If it's animal abuse then it's very simple: don't get the animal. No one is forcing you to get a cat (or Husky). If you can't care for an animal responsibly then don't get one at all. If you find one in the wild don't interact with it, and let it be wild - don't further damage the environment (more than we already have) so you can pet a cat once in a while.
I realize you aren't going to change your mind, you seem pretty dug in. So I implore you to at least ensure the animal is spayed or neutered, and to consider not getting a new cat once the current one has passed on. Please, it's just better for everyone involved.
Wow... How thoughtful...
Norwegian Forest cat is the most normal cat breed there is here. If this had been as big of a problem you mention it would have been in our news already. These cats came here in the Vikings era, it would have been a noticeable problem by now..
Yes all my cats are neutered at the age of 6months or so.
And again, this cat breed is a very normal breed here. Even if I were to not get another doesn't mean the rest of Norway isn't.
Okay, so your arguments are:
(1) Is, hopefully, very obviously subjective. Just because you haven't seen a news article about it does not mean it's a problem. And unfortunately, being a couple thousand years old does not come close to the massive amount of time it took the ecosystems to get this way. By Earth's history standards, these cats have been there for a blink of an eye.
(2) Is never a good excuse to do anything. It's group think and it's a massive problem in society. I may as well justify owning slaves because "other people aren't going to stop". You surely see how nothing will change if everyone thinks that way.
I'm very glad to gear you neuter the cat at least. It's at least helping combat the issue a bit.
I just want to make the world a better place, that's all. I'm not trying to attack or shame you, I just want to save the birds (and cats) :(
I didnt mean to come across cross.. but my main point is that these cats are meant to be outdoors, as well as indoors. They love the mixture between being active outside and resting inside. I can't keep these cats indoors only - thats not what they want nor what the vet recommends. I do see the problem of them ruining other wildlife, however, I can't limit them to being indoors either. I love birds and wildlife myself, and at the cabin we have loooads of bird feeders and bird boxes setup, which is a very enjoyable sight all-year round. While I do, and will continue to let my cats outdoors, I try do my part for a better wildlife other places. Not perfect, but something.
I appreciate you being aware of the impact at least, it's all I can really ask. I hope you can find some way to limit the cat's impact on the environment, like perhaps a bell on their collar
And I'm glad you put food out for the birds. I do the same and I find such joy in watching them, they're truly beautiful :)