Emphasis mine. Being anti-genocide is bad and can cost your tenured job. But being pro-genocide is okay.

Another key moment in Finkelstein's tensions with the college in the previous 11 months [was] her reaction to a fundraising campaign for the Israeli military promoted on campus. Finkelstein told me that on October 17, on leaving her classroom, she was shocked by a display table newly laid out by Hillel.

"You can help raise money for various war efforts in Israel," a sign on the table read, followed by QR codes linking to campaigns, including one to raise money for the Israeli military. Finkelstein did not immediately post publicly about the fundraiser, but emailed the school's president, chaplain, and director of Hillel.

"How, in good conscience, can the college allow for this to be displayed to our students? The Israeli military just bombed a hospital in Gaza, killing 500 people," she wrote. "I think this is an absolute disgrace. I hope it will be taken down ASAP." Following several complaints to university leadership, Finkelstein was, she said, told that the Hillel students had a right to fundraise for whichever cause they wanted.

"I asked if, since students had the right to fundraise for genocide, whether I or anyone else — other faculty, students — had the freedom to write about it, and was told yes," said Finkelstein. The following day, she posted a picture of the fundraiser sign to her X and Instagram accounts, without naming Muhlenberg as the location. "Students raising money for genocide," she wrote. "Grief won't be extinguished by revenge — ceasefire now."

I don't know anything about academia and maybe this is typical for it. Still my response is holy fuck. I'm shocked that the uni used outside consultants as a PR heat shield and any uni can cherry pick a firm that will give them the result they want.

While Finkelstein was put on leave, the third-party investigation into the case was conducted by D. Stafford & Associates, a consulting firm specializing in campus safety and law enforcement. The investigation, which concluded in April, found that Finkelstein's Instagram repost rose to the level of violating the school's equal opportunity, nondiscrimination policies, which can police extramural speech in addition to classroom conduct.

Finkelstein had to literally define words for the provost

"She didn't seem to understand what I meant by Zionist," Finkelstein said, recounting her experience of an October meeting with Furge, the provost. "And so I explained to her that Judaism is a religion and Zionism is a political ideology."

having seen shit go down, a lot of people wildly misunderstood what tenure is it what it does to protect the individual, full professor at a university. in truth, it is a feather in the cap for careerists and allows them to Lord over younger faculty. it is granted by the institution to people who bring in a lot of money to the institution, in other words, people who are good at navigating the political economy of funding institutions.

if you go against the president of a university publicly, it will be stripped from you and you will be shit canned. if you make yourself an enemy of administration or, in the instance if publicly supported institutions, get in the radar of a politician holding ourselves strings in a negative way, or if you jeopardize the reputation of the institution, it will be stripped from you. if you don't basically keep doing what you've been doing and bringing $ in, you can lose it too.

it basically only protects you if you're the sort of senior faculty who doesn't really need or deserve any protection.

All these antisemitic Finkelsteins, huh