Upvote, cause in principle you make the right argument and I think Jasmine is tone deaf to use cotton picking as an example.
But let's be honest. Americans don't want to perform low paid heavy manual labour.
They aren't going to be manufacturing garments in factories or picking peaches from the fields any time soon.
So I have to credit her for making a good argument, even if she chose the wrong example.
I fully agree.
Also, one thing that Unions always have trouble with is that there is no individual benefit to joining a union, only a cost, so you get a prisoners dilemma type situation.
Even in Scandinavian countries, union membership is on the decline.
Personally, I think the solution should be that union dues are paid by a small tax, making it 'free' to join a union. And the unions can provide free benefits to their members, such as legal advice and representation. This will make it attractive to join a union.