31
Israel's spin about hospital massacre quickly comes apart
(electronicintifada.net)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 18 Oct 2023
31 points (59.3% liked)
World News
37213 readers
984 users here now
News from around the world!
Rules:
-
Please only post links to actual news sources, no tabloid sites, etc
-
No NSFW content
-
No hate speech, bigotry, propaganda, etc
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
I'm not reading a blog from "electronic intifada", just like I'm not reading the rants section of "holy land settlers .net".
The IDF is wrong. Hamas is wrong. They are both wrong. This is not a contradiction.
The best way I've seen it put was that "Israel's response goes beyond the scope of defense"
Yeah... since 1949.
Here's an incident Israeli feds almost certainly faked. And you're like. Both sides bad.
Good for you, condemning all sides from your ivory tower so you can maintain moral purity.
So! What do you think Hamas should have done? Vote? Start a petition? Post about it on X?
Are you trying to suggest that Hamas were some how justified in intentionally killing innocent civilians?
Not having an answer doesn’t mean you can’t condemn both sides in this.
I can't speak for the person you were responding to... but yes - Hamas (and every other organisation Palestinians choose to support) has every goddamn right to fight Israel in whatever way that works. And no... I am in no way suggesting that - I'm stating it outright.
Advocating for the slaughtering of innocent civilians is disgusting.
Israel has been doing tons of that since 1949 - where were you and the rest of the pearl-clutchers all this time?
Not advocating for the slaughtering of innocent civilians, because I'm not a monster.
And offering nothing but slap-on-the-wrist apologetics for Israel's decades-old genocide while demonising Palestinians when they fight back makes you (somehow) less of a monster?
When did I do that?
This you?
Sure is, good job!
What about it?
So you admit to glossing over Israel's decades-long genocide?
That's remarkably honest for a liberal.
Nope, I admit to saying that advocating for the slaughtering of innocent civilians is disgusting.
If you think those 2 things are the same, then you might have brain damage.
Riiiight... those of us who know better calling attention to the fact that you libs only began worrying about the "slaughtering of innocent civilians" as soon as Israel was handed a miniscule taste of it's own medicine are doing so because... "brain damage".
Riiiight.
Here. This wasn't written for you - it was written to satirize you.
It's funny, because you have to invent those things about me, while I can link to where you actively advocated for the slaughtering of innocent civilians.
I guess that's the best someone with your level of brain damage can do, though. So sad.
No, there's nothing funny about people minimising Israel's 80-year genocide because "Hamas bad".
And you can't even claim "brain damage" as an excuse.
I don’t see here where anyone is trying to justify Israel. They’re wrong. So are Hamas. It’s that simple.
Here... you dropped some of your pro-Israel "both-side-ism" tropes - let me point it out for you.
I don't support Israel though?
Did you reply to the wrong person?
When you are trying to accuse someone of supporting the slaughtering civilians, and they aren't supporting Israel in this particular conflict, then by definition they aren't supporting the slaughtering of innocent civilians.
On the other hand, if you are criticizing Hamas for attacking valid Israeli targets in their fight for freedom, you are implicitly supporting the slaughter of civilians. i.e. you support the fact that Israel regularly bombs hospitals and evacuation routes.
You’re entitled to your opinion. I do wonder if it would change if it was your mum or brother or some other loved one that gets killed while minding their own business but whatever. In your mind, Hamas would be justified for it.
I am perfectly capable of understanding the point of view of a person who has had their entire family and/or community murdered, imprisoned or forced to flee - but having that happen to one over and over again for almost 80 years while privileged scum runs interference for the perpetrators because it's simply more convenient to swallow the well-funded propaganda... that stretches the limits of even my imagination.
It actually does, because it means you're just playing pretend instead of grappling with the world as it actually exists.
So shut up 😘
I dunno they could like try to negotiate and settle on something else then the complete extermination of all Israelis and Jews, just an idea
Riiight... let's justify an actual and ongoing genocide by hiding behind an alleged one that doesn't exist.
Why does this sound so familiar? Oh, right... it's the exact same "reverse genocide" trope the Apartheid-regime hid behind so long.
Alleged genocide? Hamas isnt even hiding that their biggest goal is to eradicate Israel and all Jews living there. They openly say it since they came into existence. Their goal in the war they started now was to kill as many people (doesnt matter if they were civilians or even foreigners) as possible. What is alleged here? Its all official.
On the other hand, Israel's goal is to kill Hamas, not civilians (even if edgelords on the internet wont see it that way and will scream apartheid and genocide without even know what that means), but that's pretty hard to do when they're cowardly hiding behind children.
Yes, Clyde... an alleged genocide - you know, the one that only exists in your white supremacism-addled mind? You know... unlike the very real genocide Israel has been perpetrating since 1949? Complete with applause from fascist garbage-peddlers like you?
Riiiiight... and I suppose next you'll be telling me the Nazis were only targeting "Jewish-Bolshevism" and not all Jewish people, eh fascist?
WTF im a nazi because unlike you i dont support a terror organization? TF is wrong with you people.
Firstly, Palestinian representatives including Hamas have tried to come to the negotiating table, ever since the beginning. The response from Israel is bombing runs, artillery fire, and bad faith claims that Hamas will not negotiate.
Secondly, Palestinians do not want to exterminate anyone, they simply want to be free. The extermination/genocide thing is common myth presented by settlers who can't imagine anything but genocide, as it's how their own society has been built, and they project this on to all other societies.
And how do they force Israel to negotiate?
Israel won't negotiate with peaceful protestors and won't negotiate with hostage takers and won't negotiate with passive captives. Just an idea, but maybe Israel is the one at fault for there being no negotiations.