56
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 07 Mar 2024
56 points (72.6% liked)
Games
16737 readers
404 users here now
Video game news oriented community. No NanoUFO is not a bot :)
Posts.
- News oriented content (general reviews, previews or retrospectives allowed).
- Broad discussion posts (preferably not only about a specific game).
- No humor/memes etc..
- No affiliate links
- No advertising.
- No clickbait, editorialized, sensational titles. State the game in question in the title. No all caps.
- No self promotion.
- No duplicate posts, newer post will be deleted unless there is more discussion in one of the posts.
- No politics.
Comments.
- No personal attacks.
- Obey instance rules.
- No low effort comments(one or two words, emoji etc..)
- Please use spoiler tags for spoilers.
My goal is just to have a community where people can go and see what new game news is out for the day and comment on it.
Other communities:
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
I've wondered what the term was for someone who acts like an incel, but might have had sex at one point or another. I guess it's "anti-woke", or whatever they're calling themselves now.
The word is fascist.
I wish that was why.
Fuck me sideways, do I wish that was why.
The actual reason - if you are a person who cares about reasons - is that their opinions amount to ingroup-supremacist reactionary violence. These people reliably mumble that they're 'not against' the barest recognition of ethnic, sexual, or cultural minorities, they're just against it 'when it's forced.' And then you press them the tiniest bit and find out they'll call literally any inclusion 'forced.'
Incel rhetoric didn't cause mass shootings by accident. It's the same emotionally-manipulative, grievance-driven, scapegoat-centric, cult-of-machismo bullshit that Eco described in Ur-Fascism, thirty-odd years ago. These people getting mad at video games are cut from that same mold. "Gamergate" in particular has demonstrable immediate ties to right-wing assholes making shit up to rattle a bunch of undersocialized young men into harassing women and minorities off the internet and into hiding.
Sometimes taking what seems like the right stand on an issue can deepen the harm - be careful about getting too extreme.
For example when the whole "gamergate" thing was going on and people were like "Why can't I just enjoy Tomb Raider?" - one side was standing up for diversity and inclusion by denouncing them as basement-dwelling incels who should self-terminate. So that naturally drove some to those right-wing assholes.
Sometimes it takes a bit of work to change someone's context so they can get closer to your perspective.
You can’t reason someone out of an opinion they didn’t reason themselves into.
Exceptionally well written explanation. Thanks! :)
But they seem to be so critical of "bad writing" that includes diversity, and seem to never talk about bad writing that doesn't include diversity. If nothing else, it's suspicious.
Did having a female protagonist ruin Star Wars?
I think Star Wars was destined to be ruined by the time Disney bought it. Hell, people had been saying the franchise was dead since at least episode I...
It's "conservative."
No no, its just "woke". The only way woke people can get laid is by extortion.
Can you explain what you mean by woke?
So, that means almost nothing is woke then? Because I see very few requirements for when something "fits the story". There's a lot of shitty writing though, always has been and always will be, but according to you, when a white guy has crap writing, it's just crap writing, but when a black woman has crappy writing, it's woke?
Esg has opened the flood gates for poor writing, we are used to the hero tale where someone comes from a normal to difficult background, theyre thrown into a situation they cant handle and so they must become strong, they in the end do become strong and that is the character ark.
Investment check boxing has made a scene where character arks are avoided, a black woman can't be viewed as week as the company's esg score will go down so now there is media depicting only strong character which is highly unrelatable.
I am all for inclusivity but it need to be done right and not for an investment rating, its akin to rainbow flag banners on socials whilst funding a racists campaign.
I think you need to remove the rose-coloured glasses, and look at how much utter crap there used to be 20 years ago. Or 10 years. Or 50 years.
You're pretty much cherrypicking all the shitty-writing-with-non-white/male-characters, and completely ignoring all the shitty-writing-with-white-male-characters. 90% of everything is crap, but if you cherrypick all the diverse characters that suck, then yeah, you're going to find a lot of shitty diverse characters.
I didn't pick anything, there has and will always be shitty writing. But that doesn't mean I'm okay with it, especially when race, gender, sexuality are used as a vehicle to profit whilst adding little to no substance.
The issue is obvious where we can't risk having a weak diverse character as it could harm esp rating and in turn profits, so we have a diverse characters that are strong and aren't relatable.
Look at game like Hellblade Senuas Sacrifice, it wasn't made to appease the esg system, yet its opened people up to mental health, gender, power struggles. Hands down its amazing story telling.
Not a game but the documentary about Jeffrey Dahmer that was recently aired on netflix was also eye open, then there the old but gold Rosemary's Baby again great story telling.
As if white guys are the default and it's everyone else who's different.
"I'm angry at black people so it's their fault!"
Aaand blocked.
I think they are saying most attempts at diversity come from middle aged white guys and just end up being poorly done and so detract from the game/story.
Similar to how 00's electronic companies just painted it pink to appeal to women or why South Park added Token.
So arguing for more diversity within the companies themselves
They're grasping for excuses to whine about the existence of other people.
Stop giving bigots endless benefit-of-the-doubt.
You are far worse than the people you are claiming to act against.
Lots of people can feel something is a problem and struggle to articulate it. So you have to take people on a case by case basis.
OP talks about how they feel diverse characters are shoe horned in or badly written. Ask them to provide an example.
When they can't, then call them out. They are a bigot and deserve scorn.
If they can provide an example, help them understand the issue and use appropriate language.
Calling someone out who genuinely feels there is a problem doesn't stop them feeling there is a problem. These people will go looking for some who acknowledges their feelings.
Which is how you make a bigot
"It's your fault that bigot's a bigot, because you called out their bigoted feelings. All they did was articulate how black people in a video game was a conspiracy! Why didn't you ask for more examples of their wackaloon thinking?!"
Fuck off.
You could have a main female character in Mass Effect but it never felt shoehorned in like a lot of crap these days. In fact I have never played Male!Shep.
Lmao, what?
Being aware of societal issues affecting minority populations is a magnificent way to get laid.
Even South Park parodied it!
It doesn't seem weird that caring about others can be a very attractive trait in a person.
Hold on, have to confess to my wife that I've been extorting her, wish me luck
Thinking this is about access to vaginas is a crystal clear example of the cult of machismo.
lol. This is your brain on the manosphere.
“Could the “woke” fellas be getting laid simply by treating women like human beings rather than objects? No, it’s obviously extortion.”