Every episode:

Mulder: Scully it was aliens

Scully: No Mulder it wasn't aliens

Mulder: Look, an alien!

Scully: No Mulder aliens aren't real

Mulder: Scully there is literally one standing next to you and waving

Scully: Hmm, maybe but I'm not fully convinced

That's it, that's every episode. And I love it

Mulder and Scully are the only FBI agents I will never cancel.

i have to imagine that scully and mulder are going through a million x files offscreen that aren't supernatural and the ones that are supernatural become the episodes we see. its never said in the show, but thats my own justification for it

It's funny when it's a religion thing, then it's Scully who isn't skeptical at all. Angels? Oh yeah, absolutely. Gotta be angels. And Mulder is the consummate skeptic if it's ANYTHING spiritual

It definitely gets a little more absurd the longer the series goes on, but I still love it.

And in Scully's defense she does have a tendency to get conveniently knocked unconscious or frozen in ice, or locked in a random room, or detained by security at a perimeter fence a lot when the actual spooky shit reveals itself.

There's definitely some Monster of the Week episodes that feel out of step with her skepticism vs experiences, but I think the mythology episodes (and mythology adjacent episodes) do a pretty good job of having both Scully and Mulder's respective faiths and skepticisms evolve and change. They even kind of cross over when Mulder has his "this is a conspiracy of men" crisis of faith before the arrival of the alien rebels.

I've always kind of read Scully's seemingly contrary religiosity and hard anti-alien skepticism as a reflection of or exploration of Chris Carter's own seemingly conflicted religious beliefs. He was brought up in a religious household but his older brother rejected it for science and introduced him to sci-fi before eventually becoming a professor at MIT. You can tell Chris Carter feels trapped between his fascination with both and I always read Scully, especially in the earlier seasons, as his attempt to square that circle.

It does get a little funkier later on, by the late 90s and that may be because it's heavily (and seemingly reliably) rumoured that Carter got into Scientology. While the religious themes and iconography in his writing only seems to increase, it feels like there's a lot more frustration with 'mainstream' religion not fitting a broader, more esoteric spiritual and paranormal tone. Scully's skeptic/religious balance feels less like an earnest attempt at squaring a circle and more like an example that the two rigid ways of looking at her life cannot hold. I think you can read that as Carter's frustration with both traditional religious communities and the scientific/skeptic community as he embraces Scientology.

But also, Chris Carter is kind of a weirdo misogynist whose own sexism and poor character writing pretty much destroyed Scully's character and pretty much cancelled and then doomed the show more than once. So fuck him.

Also, I probably watch and think about the X Files too much.

Uzumaki is the same lmfao every issue has the bf being like "I think there is something really weird going on with spirals in this town, we should gtfo" and main character is like "noooooooo what are you talking about haha" as though her aunt didn't just turn into a spiral and try to kill her yesterday

Well, yeah. That’s why she was brought onto the team. The higher ups wanted a “logical” explanation for Mulder’s antics. She can’t exactly say “You’re right Mulder. I do believe in aliens. But I will keep telling Skinner that maybe it was Chinese swamp gas.” The deep state actually don’t care, or need her to deboonk everything or else the deep state is exposed.

In season 8 she's the believer.

I remember there was a supercut of her "are you trying to tell me...," "would you have me believe...," etc. as part of a behind-the-scenes type thing or a tv special... amazingly, it doesn't appear to be on YouTube

Yeah, that's why she's so good.