57
submitted 2 months ago by rtstragedy@hexbear.net to c/games@hexbear.net

(note: the camera mode in the remake was all over the place for gamma adjustment and had all sorts of oddities. i hope you get the impression from the pictures anyway. wtb a keyboard with a print screen button)

(also note: this is like my first ever post on this site, feel free to idk take it down if this is the wrong spot or something)

I love game environments. Here's a shortlist of games I love because of their environments:

  • SOMA
  • Subnautica
  • probably other ocean games
  • Skyrim (because I like snowy mountains, ask me about my childhood cross-country train ride)
  • Riven

I probably wouldn't want to live in the world of PATHOS-II (SOMA), or on 4546B (Subnautica) because of the real actual dangers, but Riven's danger feels a lot more abstract. So the world is ending, whatever, that's Atrus' problem.

myst, cyan, etc.

I played Myst as a tiny thing, somewhere after Reader Rabbit and Mario is Missing and before Half-Life. I liked it fine, spent a bunch of time with it, but couldn't crack the puzzles. I was like not even 10 lol.

I remember being fascinated by the Making Of Myst video that came with the CD version of the game. The scene of the sound designer blowing bubbles into the toilet is a thing I think about a lot. It's 15 minutes, you can watch it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c5af74KuJZE

intro about the game

But, when I got older, my dad bought me a copy of Riven. The game came on 5 CDs (which I unfortunately no longer have, due to the Satanic Panic). I'm playing the Steam copy for this one, but I own the remake on gog due to drm-free.

Riven was my absolute jam. It Fucking Slaps. It Rules. It's a sequel, but it looks better. It's bigger. The puzzles are more intuitive. It includes a setup screen that instructs you how to not only calibrate your monitor but also your speakers, with examples of dark/quiet and bright/loud to compare.

The tram rides are sick as hell. Each island has its own vibe. The sound was such a huge factor and it felt so real to me on my tiny CRT and $5 computer speakers.

And, someone bought me the strategy guide. Here's a picture of it:

The graphics absolutely still hold up. Sometimes, when I look at Myst Island, I see how small the ages are these days, but by comparison, Riven has so many places to be.

Each island has its own CD, generally, and while there are 5 islands I actually can't remember what the 5th disc was used for, lol.

I'm not going for complete coverage of the game here, this post is already really long, and I doubt anyone is going to read it all, lol, so I'll just highlight some things.

temple island

Okay, so you start on what you'll later find is called Temple Island, and in here is the most infamous and ANNOYING puzzle of the game (you know, other than the math).

The Rotating Gate Room Puzzle sucks, imo. It is cool, if it's the first time you are playing the game. It is bearable, if you are able to skip the movement cutscene (I believe you had to time it right IIRC). In the remake, you cannot skip the movement animation. It is so tedious.

But it is iconic and it's one of the first puzzles in the game and sets the tone. This puzzle is a feast for the eyes and the ears. The gate room, it looks like this:

All of those scarabs on the wall have stained glass portraits in them, depicting the religion of the people of Riven.

Behind the first door is The Dome. THE DOME. It is gigantic. It is golden. It is the focal point of Riven, by far the most iconic landmark in the game. Here are two pictures of The Dome:

Here is a picture of the inside of the Dome (no, it's not as important. who cares, it's The Dome):

And, when you spin the gate room, there is a multi-layered, complex sound of stones moving, gears turning, the creaking of heavy things not normally willing to move. This sound teleports me back to being a tiny thing, before puberty, before dysphoria, before I learned that the way I acted, moved, and felt were "wrong." All that existed was this world, for me. And this annoying fucking room.

You interact with very few people in Riven. This is great for me, for reasons that should be obvious. I'm sure, to a lot of people, that this would creep them out. I find this calming, personally. I love these big and lived in environments, and I like being able to explore them without too many people to get in the way. There are still people in Riven, they're just hiding.

Sure, at the beginning, Atrus is all there talking about his wife, his dad, something about an apocalypse, and the plot is interesting, but I don't care about that. I want to fucking live here. I'm serious. I will live in those tiny fucking huts. Here's a picture of the tiny fucking huts:

(Yeah, how even do these houses on the left even work? like, the door is on the bottom? If you open the door, does all your shit fall out?)

Anyway, the gate puzzle isn't that complicated. Here's a picture from the strategy guide:

You just have to unlock the gates in the right order by spinning the room a billion times to get into the dome.

I get a bit fuzzy about the order of things on Temple Island, actually, because the layout of Temple Island changed in the remake a bit.

There's one more area on Temple Island. Look at this chamber:

It's neat. Says a lot about the world in its design. Of course, this isn't a happy game about good things. Maybe I should talk about the plot for a minute.

the plot

Okay, so you've probably played Myst. The idea is that you, the player, come across a random book at some point (I think this is supposed to be on Earth), touch the page and do a little whoopsie and you end up on the shores of Myst Island.

Where did that book come from? Well, my video game dad, Atrus, dropped it into a thing called the Star Fissure. This is the opening line of Myst:

I realized, the moment I fell into the fissure, that the book would not be destroyed as I had planned. It continued falling into that starry expanse of which I had only a fleeting glimpse. I have tried to speculate where it might have landed, but I must admit, however— such conjecture is futile. Still, the question of whose hands might someday hold my Myst book are unsettling to me. I know that my apprehensions might never be allayed, and so I close, realizing that perhaps, the ending has not yet been written.

(wow, is this quote really that long? I only really remembered the first line)

Damn, that's intriguing, right? Well, fuck you, apparently, if you only played Myst, because there's barely an answer in that game. Only Riven explains this, so what is Riven?

Riven is a place, called an Age. It's like a planet or something. These Ages are created by only a very few people in the multiverse, who have the ability to "write Ages." There's a bit of confusion about what happens when you burn an Age book, though, which has come up - I think that there are actually two kinds of books: One that actually define the structure of an Age, and one that links to the existing Age. Atrus appears to be writing the source code for Riven as he talks to you. Cool, I can dig that.

He's writing in the book because Riven is falling apart, his wife is trapped there, and his dad is a jerk who wants to subjugate all the ages or something, really power-hungry shit. So, he sends you there, promising that you may end up "back where you came from" once all of this is through.

Okay, so how is Riven falling apart? Well, the age is literally splitting at the seams, but what is in between the seams is actually what's known as the Starry Expanse. At the bottom? Earth, apparently, which is how the Myst book got there in the first place. I wont go further into all the family drama, but it's there in various books in the game if you like to read. You probably like to read, right? Well, I won't blame you if you're only looking at the pictures in this post. It took me a very long time to upload all these pictures, so you're welcome!

jungle island

So, you make it across the tram and you enter the biggest island in the game, Jungle Island.

Jungle Island doesn't immediately start with the jungle, but instead makes you climb up a huge flight of stairs to a former forest full of stumps.

There's a lot that I like about this place. I like the forest shrine:

I like the village, with its strange houses (see above)

And I like the beach, with the lazy creatures: (called "sunners" in the stragedy guide):

But what I like best is the transit platform on the entrance from Temple Island. In VR, you can just walk (or teleport in my case) around, so when I came to the edge of this platform I just kinda sat down IRL. I happened to have a fan going, pointing at me from the direction of the wind, actually. It was chill. I was immersed. I wish I could bring a book and read here, or eat my lunch, watching the ocean. I used to live in a coastal city, and the only thing that stopped me from really enjoying the shore was all the people. Here, there is no one. It's perfect. (Oh, and the sun doesn't feel weird on my skin.)

Occassionally, earthquakes will happen, but so what? The world's not actually going to end, probably.

If I'm being honest, I dream of falling through the Starry Expanse. I imagine it is a nice temperature. Quiet. No one else around ... Peaceful. Just like the platform on Jungle Island, there's nothing chaotic or demanding of me, no one to judge me or make me feel stupid for the way I am even just with their existence, even when they're trying to be nice. On the platform, it's nothing but the sound of the waves, and a world that's falling apart. Only I can do something about the world falling apart, but it's too much pressure on me (and the solution involves math, blech), so I stay on the platform. In the end, even if you do learn how to count, Riven does fall apart, and Catherine evacuates its people so a safer Age. Atrus then shows up and takes her home, leaving you there to fall, fall out of the world, out of your responsibilites, out of people's expectations - so loud that they are - into the Starry Expanse, where, at the end, you might finally find your home.

Atrus to me feels like a friend, or my real dad, I don't know why. Maybe because I grew up seeing his dumb little desk in the chamber he's trapped in in D'ni, trying to fix Riven, and the mistakes of his family, feeling responsibility for their actions. Maybe I can relate to that feeling. Maybe I can relate to Rand Miller, the man behind Atrus and the creator of the game, who has devoted his life to making these kinds of worlds, even after his brother Robyn left to pursue other kinds of art, steadfastedly against game industry trends and the death of the adventure game.

I don't really imagine what lies at the bottom of my Starry Expanse to be Earth, but that's what's so captivating about it to me. I moved around a lot when I was young. There's some relief, when you make as many dumb mistakes and get ostracized as much as I did when I was young, to being able to just leave.

Okay, but you're not into shores and self-pity, so let me show you a couple more .jpgs and then wrap up.

crater island

Remember that stump photo above? Well, there's a minecart in a hole there that you can ride, presumably that's where the former forest went. When you ride it, you go fucking underwater and it's a total roller coaster. No, I haven't tried this in VR. I get sick if literally any motion happens whatsoever in VR (leave your tips below so that I can say I've already tried them!!). But, it's fucking sick in the original. You're underwater, and there's these heating rings (because all the water in Riven has some kind of temperature sensitive microbes in it) that push the water away, and the colours and the contrast and the motion are so fucking sick. I would take this ride back and forth repeatedly as a tiny thing. (sorry, the camera mode in game really broke the visuals here, but just imagine the coolest thing ever)

Anyway, I like crater island, because it looks sad on the surface:

Yep, nothing to see here. But, I like this anyway, maybe because I can relate to that. Check out this boiler (it's a puzzle!):

And... if you make it all the way through this, you find a bridge all the way back to Temple Island. This is necessary path, and it goes right back to The Dome. So that's cool. Crater island has a new area in the remake. I cut this image because of the rate limit and well I guess my excuse will be that it is spoilers for the remake haha not that I want 15 minutes back.

the remake

So, some further thoughts on the remake. The golden dome looks beautiful, and for the brief time that I got HDR working on Linux in order to play this game, it ruled. Inner child activated.

But, since you can move around at the speed of an FPS, the game world feels smaller. I spent most of my time stuck on Temple island because they moved a thing and I was in disbelief that they would move that room wtf, that's not where it goes. (Actually, the new location is better). I am glad some puzzles were changed, but I was really disappointed with how quickly I went through Plateau Island especially, since it's usually a bigger part of the game. I'm sure if I was trying to figure out what to do it'd be longer, but I feel like the iconic elevator ride was really short.

There's other changes. They're neat.

The VR mode runs like crap, it's super blurry too because they lower the resolution in VR mode. I can get 140fps in 1440p on this thing in flatscreen, but in VR it's like oh no 46fps for you, enjoy your nausea in the gate room. But I'll keep trying to get it running better.

One change is bad though: I miss the FMV characters. Everyone does. These characters are a bit uncanny. (better than Myst remake though imo)

Okay, I'm out of steam here. Thanks for reading my little disorganized rant. Hope you liked the screenshots. I didn't make the world, but I sure did take the pictures. I guess that makes me a Riven photographer.

top 31 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[-] ashinadash@hexbear.net 12 points 2 months ago

changed in the remake.

Nice this just has one, Myst has like six different versions or something, lol lmao. These are all at... 1035x714, 960x540 though? PS Vita res? I assume Riven doesn't actually run at that.

Despite the fact that I had basically no interest in playing any Cyan games and I might still not, but I'm growing an appreciation for these dorky things. The plot actually sounds kinda cool, and even aside the cool visual design the CG has aged remarkably well.

Only I can do something about the world falling apart, but it's too much pressure on me (and the solution involves math, blech), so I stay on the platform.

real as fuck

since you can move around at the speed of an FPS, the game world feels smaller.

Do you think point-jumping movement would have worked better for VR? Might have helped the motion sickness at least.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 9 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

Nice this just has one, Myst has like six different versions or something, lol lmao.

tru, i have played a few of the Myst remakes. They are all janky in their own way, lol.

These are all at... 1035x714, 960x540 though? PS Vita res? I assume Riven doesn't actually run at that.

No, I cropped these to frame them a bit, and sized them down just to go easy on HB's servers. I wasn't sure how the rate limiting was going to go, haha.

The plot actually sounds kinda cool, and even aside the cool visual design the CG has aged remarkably well.

Yeah I didn't want to put too much effort into this, first post and all, I was originally planning on doing some side-by-sides. Riven is incredible in its original form as an interactive slideshow as well, but just a lower resolution.

Do you think point-jumping movement would have worked better for VR? Might have helped the motion sickness at least.

totally, i use teleport movement in basically every game (that's what you meant, right?) I played this game first on flatscreen, which is where this comment came from. but even in VR with teleport, it feels fast. maybe that's because I know where everything is.

however, this game ran so bad in VR that just moving my head around trying to do the gate puzzle quickly spent me because of the low framerate.

thanks for reading :)

[-] ashinadash@hexbear.net 8 points 2 months ago

I sort of noticed that, do you have thoughts on any of the remastered 2D versions like the 1999 Master edition or w/e, or is the very original the way to go?

Oh okay, cropping makes more sense. Nice crops nerd!

It surprises me that they didn't keep the teleport-movement then, tons of VR games have it since virtual locomotion is kinda spicy. Also yeah, low framerates in VR are awful, rip.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 7 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

I sort of noticed that, do you have thoughts on any of the remastered 2D versions like the 1999 Master edition or w/e, or is the very original the way to go?

So actually, I've played/seen 4 of them:

  • Original. I haven't gone back to this one, honestly. It's the one I played when I was young though, so I know it's pretty good.
  • realMyst Masterpiece Edition. At the time I wanted to play Myst again, and this was the one, it promised full 3d movement instead of slideshow. It was ok, but it was a bit janky iirc.
  • Sega Saturn version of the original. This is Partner's nostalgia, but it sure does load a lot in between each frame. I got it for him last year for his birthday present and he really enjoyed playing it again. i watched. it was good, but slow, lol.
  • Myst (the remake). We just played this this week, Partner played it in VR. It also has the blurry problems, but he didn't notice since he doesn't wear his glasses in the headset. Advantage to him, I guess. It was a bit janky with the teleports, it doesn't feel like the most natural VR experience, but when I asked him a second ago he said "it was a fun vibe. it was fun to hang out. Probably not the way I'd recommend someone play Myst, but." (yes, that's how he ended his sentence, lol) I could see myself hanging out in Myst, it ran better in VR on my PC than Riven did.

Oh okay, cropping makes more sense. Nice crops nerd!

thank you, i used whatever editor comes with KDE which didn't even have a jpeg compression slider lol, real galaxy brain over here

It surprises me that they didn't keep the teleport-movement then, tons of VR games have it since virtual locomotion is kinda spicy. Also yeah, low framerates in VR are awful, rip.

i mean, by default, in VR, both Myst and Riven have teleport movement. I definitely accidentally teleported myself into a softlock last night in Riven though... you can turn on smooth locomotion in both, i did not.

[-] RiotDoll@hexbear.net 12 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

Are you me?

My parents were way too edgy to ever take a satanic panic seriously, but other than that i felt this post deeply.

I picked up the riven remake recently and it was like flashing into my 10 year old self just absolutely in awe of that fucking game.

My first exposure was playing at a rich kid's house, using his sister's copy. Was wild shit and I got home and basically insisted on getting it for ourselves.

Gonna go play some more in a bit, awesome op.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 6 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

My parents were way too edgy to ever take a satanic panic seriously, but other than that i felt this post deeply.

yes, well uh, i took it seriously, since i guess i didn't understand that it was kind of a bit. i would have people like my grandma whine about "devil music" and stuff, and read the things online, and then do regular purges of the things that brought me joy. Partner bought me the strategy guide for my birthday this year, so that's a little piece of my childhood that I've now reclaimed. I have some other ideas for posts about childhood things that I'm trying to reclaim, but maybe for now I will take a bit of a break from essay writing, haha. Uploading the images takes a while.

edit: whoops accidentally hit send

Are you me?

i mean, it's possible, but we do have a different pfp and technically different pronouns, but I wouldn't discount the possibility...

I picked up the riven remake recently and it was like flashing into my 10 year old self just absolutely in awe of that fucking game.

fuck yeah

Gonna go play some more in a bit, awesome op.

thank you very much!

[-] CredibleBattery@hexbear.net 11 points 2 months ago

i don't have to wish, i already live in a video game.

i live in fucking Revachol dubois-finger-guns

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 11 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

ooh, close second pick, the game does imply that the Pale is expanding though ... actually, that's really similar, isn't it? Kim is in Revachol though, and he's pretty cool ... hmmm...

[-] Infamousblt@hexbear.net 9 points 2 months ago

This post was a fucking journey and I was sad when it was over

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 6 points 2 months ago

it was going to be a lot longer, but uh, well, i didn't want to take months on it lol, so instead i took a week instead. i had to cut a couple images because i felt the rate-limit-to-payoff ratio was tilted too far in the "i want to do other things tonight" direction, haha. but thank you!

[-] BelieveRevolt@hexbear.net 8 points 2 months ago

which I unfortunately no longer have, due to the Satanic Panic

Talk about burying the lede.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 4 points 2 months ago

I didn't want to get sidetracked when writing the post, but I did write a little bit about it here as a response to RiotDoll's comment if you're interested https://hexbear.net/comment/5405003 .

[-] BelieveRevolt@hexbear.net 3 points 2 months ago

I am, I didn't realize Riven - The Sequel to Myst could be considered satanic, is there imagery like that in the game? Or was it a general "video games are of the devil" thing?

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 4 points 2 months ago

In my family, it was certain imagery, but I was young, so I interpreted it to mean "anything that I enjoy 'too much,' " because I enjoyed a lot of things that internet people, my church, my grandparents said were evil.

[-] TheDoctor@hexbear.net 6 points 2 months ago

I forgot about this game. Core memories unlocked seeing that dome. One of my favorite moments is rounding the corner to the stairs near the beginning and seeing the dinosaur (?) leap into the water. I was very young so apologies if that’s not what it actually was. Some giant creature. I thought it was going to end up being much more important than it was.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 3 points 2 months ago

Core memories unlocked seeing that dome.

this is my absolute favourite part about hearing people talk about silly little games on the internet. I feel like I'm reclaiming my childhood from the weird version of Christianity I grew up, which taught me a lot of self-hatred.

One of my favorite moments is rounding the corner to the stairs near the beginning and seeing the dinosaur (?) leap into the water.

huh, interesting. I don't remember that at all. Is it possible you're referring to the guy who gets tranq'd in the intro? I think it's implied he gets dumped in the lake in the original. here's how it looks in the remake, he's just sleeping, no Rivenese were harmed in the making of this game lol.

I found this screenshot from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMIMIC41SO4 this random playthrough I searched up, my gaming comp is downstairs haha

[-] TheDoctor@hexbear.net 3 points 2 months ago

Nah I think I’m talking about one of these

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 2 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

ah right! I was thinking about Temple Island. Yeah, the stragedy guide calls these "Sunners," and there's an audio puzzle in the original attached to the noise they make. You've gotta advance on them slowly, since they're so eepy they don't notice you until you're close, then they scream at you and you know how many points their howl is worth by matching it to a random ball somewhere on the island (and of course, you can read D'ni numbering right? right??), which you can then use if some kind of code.

[-] HexReplyBot@hexbear.net 2 points 2 months ago

I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:

[-] refracting@hexbear.net 5 points 2 months ago

My girlfriend loves Riven and I've been meaning to look into it more. Appreciate the post! It sounds really interesting

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 5 points 2 months ago

your girlfriend sounds cute and based, thanks for reading!

[-] Speaker@hexbear.net 5 points 2 months ago

Riven is the best Myst game, bar none. Also, in my experience there's no timing to skipping cutscenes: just hit Escape. Have played Riven multiple times over the years, and you better believe I'm slapping Escape for the rotating gates and that god damn tech demo water table bullshit for the fire marble puzzle.

Cool travelogue, please rant more.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 2 points 2 months ago

I think maybe what I was remembering is that you had to wait for the video animation to start to skip the gate moving - button press, wait, sound, animation, then ESC.

but yes lol tedious in a replay. I have some more logs on my mind ... we will see if they turn into anything though, haha.

[-] anaesidemus@hexbear.net 4 points 2 months ago

I read Riften and was like sure, it can be kind of cozy

Never played these Myst type games, but they evoke a certain nostalgia

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 5 points 2 months ago

If I was gonna live in Skyrim, it would be Whiterun. Because of this video, in part. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_IONpQkuiY (but mostly because it's familiar and I like the people)

[-] HexReplyBot@hexbear.net 2 points 2 months ago

I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:

[-] HexReplyBot@hexbear.net 3 points 2 months ago

I found a YouTube link in your post. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:

[-] MaeBorowski@hexbear.net 2 points 2 months ago

I was so into Myst as a kid I even read the novels. Book of Atrius was decent for what it was, as I remember it anyway, but I really loved the Book of D'ni. To this day I will still sometimes use the name of one of the major characters from that book as a screen name.

It's shocking to me how little I actually remember of it all now, but hot damn do some of the images you posted push that nostalgia button in my brain.

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 3 points 2 months ago

There are ... novels?!!!!!! Okay frick, I have to check these out, thanks!

To this day I will still sometimes use the name of one of the major characters from that book as a screen name.

That's fucking sick, my screen name is stupid lol.

It's shocking to me how little I actually remember of it all now, but hot damn do some of the images you posted push that nostalgia button in my brain.

Glad I could help!!

[-] MaeBorowski@hexbear.net 3 points 2 months ago

There are ... novels?!!!!!! Okay frick, I have to check these out, thanks!

Sure! And yep, there's three of em (plus apparently a fourth that was never finished). It's been roughly 2 decades since I've read them (chomsky-yes-honey) so I'm hesitant to sing their praises too much, but I can confidently say that as novels they are far better than I would expect any book-based-on-a-video-game has any right to be. They definitely deepen the universe and the lore, as you might imagine.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myst_Reader

Glad I could help!!

heart-sickle

[-] rtstragedy@hexbear.net 2 points 2 months ago

that's sick!! I'm gonna have to check them out, thanks!

this post was submitted on 19 Sep 2024
57 points (100.0% liked)

games

20539 readers
221 users here now

Tabletop, DnD, board games, and minecraft. Also Animal Crossing.

Rules

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS