If only they had a neighboring confederation of similarly minded states...
I think Tony Gilroy worked a lot better without the constraints of the Disney movie police. Everything is very cartoony in Rogue One.
He didn't do most of the writing they brought him in at the end to fix it up and someone else directed (Gareth Edwards).
Parts that are good are probably Gilroy, he cut the romance between Jyn and Erso and pushed to have them all die.
In Rian Johnson's defence, supposedly he wanted Leia to do the hyperdrive ram and it was changed to Holdo later by executive meddling.
Which would excuse why it's never been done before, because only a powerful force sensitive could time it right. Like Luke hitting the exhaust port etc.
Too early you just hyperdrive away, too fast the shield/tractor beams/gravity well if taking planets prevents it.
This pretty much. Even in episode One Naboo blasters were just sporting air pistols.